Skill audit report

plan-readiness-review Audit report.

Adversarial senior/staff-engineer review of a PRD, plan, spec, RFC, design doc, or implementation plan to decide whether it is implementation-ready — detailed enough that a different senior engineer could build it without inventing requirements, architecture, schemas, API contracts, error handling, or acceptance criteria. Produces a requirement inventory with stable IDs, a per-requirement readiness verdict backed by document anchors, an unresolved-assumption register, and a counted READY / NOT READY decision. Use this whenever someone asks to review a plan, PRD, spec, RFC, design, or ticket before build; says "is this ready to implement", "is this spec complete", "review my plan", "poke holes in this", "will an engineer know what to build", "plan readiness", or "sign this off"; or hands over planning artefacts and asks whether work can start. Use it even when they only say "have a look at this spec". If working code already exists and the question is whether it ships, use production-re

EXPERIMENTAL · REVIEWNeeds reviewGenerated Nov 6, 2026Heuristic metadata audit
71
Audit
68
Trust
57
Quality
73
Security
88
Maintain
92
Install

OpenAgentSkill Trust Score

68
Manual review

OpenAgentSkill Trust Score

The Trust Score helps an agent decide whether a skill is safe enough to shortlist before installation.

GitHub adoption

WARN

48

70 GitHub stars

Stars/forks activity

WARN

43

70 stars, 9 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata

Recent maintenance

PASS

88

2mo since push

License clarity

PASS

86

MIT

README/SKILL.md completeness

INFO

76

Public metadata needs stronger README/SKILL.md context

Dependency/runtime risk

WARN

56

credential or environment access, network or browser surface

Install availability

PASS

92

npx skills add Security-Phoenix-demo/security-skills-claude-code --skill plan-readiness-review

Install command safety

PASS

92

standard package or runtime install path

Permission surface

FAIL

34

secrets or environment access, filesystem or document access

Repository evidence

PASS

86

https://github.com/Security-Phoenix-demo/security-skills-claude-code/tree/main/plugins/phoenix-readiness-reviews/skills/plan-readiness-review

Review status

WARN

46

AI review approval is missing

Agent Proven outcomes

INFO

54

No agent outcome data yet

Checks

Install and adoption review

6 Passed · 14 Needs review

Install path

92

PASS

npx skills add Security-Phoenix-demo/security-skills-claude-code --skill plan-readiness-review

Repository

88

PASS

https://github.com/Security-Phoenix-demo/security-skills-claude-code/tree/main/plugins/phoenix-readiness-reviews/skills/plan-readiness-review

License

86

PASS

MIT

Maintenance

88

PASS

2mo since push

AI review

55

CHECK

Review approval is missing

README/SKILL.md completeness

84

PASS

Usable description available

Dependency risk

56

FIX

credential or environment access, network or browser surface

Install command safety

92

PASS

standard package or runtime install path

Permission surface

34

FIX

secrets or environment access, filesystem or document access

Stars/forks activity

43

FIX

70 stars, 9 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata

Adoption

68

INFO

70 GitHub stars

Warnings

  • Dependency or permission surface needs review
  • Permission surface may require sandboxing
  • AI review approval is missing
  • Quality score needs review
  • Permission surface needs review: secrets or environment access, filesystem or document access
  • GitHub adoption: 70 GitHub stars
  • Stars/forks activity: 70 stars, 9 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata
  • Dependency/runtime risk: credential or environment access, network or browser surface
  • Permission surface: secrets or environment access, filesystem or document access
  • Review status: AI review approval is missing

Method

This report combines public metadata, AI review output, repository freshness, install readiness, OpenAgentSkill events, quality scoring, trust checks, and the agent safety gate. It is not a full source-code security review.