Skip to content
OpenAgentSkill
Browsing is open · Catalog captured 2026-11-21 · Automatic updates and account services are paused.
Search & research

failure-library

An annotated library of real AI writing failure patterns with full dissection. Use to teach a writer what AI slop actually looks like, diagnose why a specific passage reads as machine-written, or explain the mechanism behind a pattern.

Deupaxx · AI review on file

Installation

Read the source and dependencies before running a command. Copying does not install or execute anything.

npx skills add Deupaxx/EveryDay-Writer --skill failure-library

About this skill


name: failure-library description: | An annotated library of real AI writing failure patterns with full dissection. Use to teach a writer what AI slop actually looks like, diagnose why a specific passage reads as machine-written, or explain the mechanism behind a pattern. license: MIT metadata: version: "0.3.0"

EW Skill — Failure Library

Reading this file as reference requires no dependencies. It is a diagnostic document, not a generation tool.

When using it during generation or teaching, read the full chain first:

  1. core/anti-ai-rules.md (read fully; Section 0 sets the standard, 0.1 sets precedence, 0.2 forbids fabrication, 9 and 10 stop over-correction)
  2. core/ai_slop_commandments.md (mechanism reference and diagnostic checklist)
  3. core/voice-profile.md (this writer's voice fingerprint)
  4. Any .md files the user has dropped in references/

When used as a teaching tool during generation: Read core/anti-ai-rules.md before pointing to examples from this library.


WHAT THIS IS

A library of real AI writing failures — not invented examples, documented patterns from actual AI-generated text found in the wild. Each entry shows the original text, names the failure pattern, and dissects exactly what went wrong.

Use this when:

  • A writer wants to understand what AI writing actually looks like so they can avoid it
  • You need to explain why a specific phrase in a draft is a failure
  • The writer asks "what does AI slop actually sound like?"

This is not a checklist. It is evidence. The patterns here are what core/anti-ai-rules.md was written to prevent.


HOW TO USE THIS LIBRARY

As a teaching reference: When a writer produces a failure pattern, point to the relevant entry: "What you wrote matches the [Pattern Name] failure — here's what it looks like at its worst and why it breaks the reader."

As a study tool: Walk through the entries with the writer. The goal is not just recognition — it's internalization. A writer who can name the pattern when they read it can catch it when they write it.

As a diagnostic: When auditing a piece, use the failure categories here to identify what type of failure is present before naming it in the WHAT CHANGED AND WHY section.


FAILURE CATEGORY 1: SIGNIFICANCE INFLATION

The pattern: The writing announces that something is important, significant, or part of a broader trend — instead of showing the thing and letting the reader draw that conclusion.

Why it fails: It tells the reader what to feel before they've felt it. It replaces specific information with a generic significance claim. The reader hasn't been shown anything; they've been instructed to be impressed.

The tell: Phrases like "marking a pivotal moment," "represents a significant shift," "contributing to the broader," "reflecting its continued relevance," "underscoring its importance."

Real example:

"The Statistical Institute of Catalonia was officially established in 1989, marking a pivotal moment in the evolution of regional statistics in Spain. The founding of Idescat represented a significant shift toward regional statistical independence."

Why this is broken: "Marking a pivotal moment" and "represented a significant shift" are empty phrases. They claim importance without demonstrating it. Remove them and the sentence loses nothing of substance — which is how you know they were never doing work.

The fix: State what actually happened. Let the significance emerge from the specifics. If the founding of a statistics institute was actually important, the importance is in what it did, not in calling it pivotal.


FAILURE CATEGORY 2: TRAILING -ING ANALYSIS

The pattern: A sentence ends with a present-participle phrase that explains the significance of what was just said. The sentence states a fact; the trailing phrase announces what it means.

Why it fails: It's the writer doing the reader's job. If the fact is significant, a competent reader will draw the inference. Explaining the inference out loud collapses the gap between writer and reader, removes the reader's active participation, and signals that the writer doesn't trust their own material.

The tell: Sentences ending in "...highlighting its importance," "...underscoring its significance," "...reflecting the broader," "...demonstrating its lasting influence," "...emphasizing the need for."

Real example:

"These works are now part of the Collections of the National Museum of Education, highlighting their historical and pedagogical significance."

Why this is broken: The placement in the National Museum of Education already implies historical and pedagogical significance. The trailing phrase is redundant at best; at worst, it makes the reader feel managed.

Another real example:

"It holds a pivotal place in the East Central Railway Zone, serving as a major railway hub with historical significance. [...] contributing to the socio-economic development of the region."

Why this is broken: "Contributing to the socio-economic development of the region" is attached to a description of train service. It adds no information. It is the AI performing significance because it was trained to perform significance after stating facts.

The fix: End the sentence before the trailing phrase. Trust the fact.


FAILURE CATEGORY 3: ECOSYSTEM BOILERPLATE

The pattern: Writing about any subject — especially biological, ecological, or community-related — includes language about its importance to the broader ecosystem, broader community, or broader trend, even when that importance is tenuous or entirely generic.

Why it fails: It's filler that sounds authoritative. The phrase "plays a vital role in the ecosystem" applied to a random endemic plant species is meaningless — every organism plays some role in its ecosystem by definition. The specificity is zero. The word count increases. The reader learns nothin

Read the complete source ↗