Skill audit report
magpie-committer-onboarding Audit report.
Post-vote committer and PMC onboarding for Apache projects. Walks the nominator through every step from ICLA check to welcome announcement for both incubating podlings and graduated top-level projects.
OpenAgentSkill Trust Score
OpenAgentSkill Trust Score
The Trust Score helps an agent decide whether a skill is safe enough to shortlist before installation.
GitHub adoption
WARN48
87 GitHub stars
Stars/forks activity
WARN53
87 stars, 85 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata
Recent maintenance
PASS88
1mo since push
License clarity
PASS86
Apache-2.0
README/SKILL.md completeness
INFO76
Public metadata needs stronger README/SKILL.md context
Dependency/runtime risk
INFO72
command execution surface
Install availability
PASS92
npx skills add apache/magpie --skill magpie-committer-onboarding
Install command safety
PASS92
standard package or runtime install path
Permission surface
INFO62
shell or command execution, filesystem or document access
Repository evidence
PASS86
https://github.com/apache/magpie/tree/main/skills/committer-onboarding
Review status
INFO66
AI review data available
Agent Proven outcomes
INFO54
No agent outcome data yet
Checks
Install and adoption review
Install path
92
npx skills add apache/magpie --skill magpie-committer-onboarding
Repository
88
https://github.com/apache/magpie/tree/main/skills/committer-onboarding
License
86
Apache-2.0
Maintenance
88
1mo since push
AI review
55
The provided SKILL.md excerpt cuts off mid-sentence under Golden rule 4, so the full vote-bar verification procedure is not visible in the review excerpt.
README/SKILL.md completeness
84
Usable description available
Dependency risk
72
command execution surface
Install command safety
92
standard package or runtime install path
Permission surface
62
shell or command execution, filesystem or document access
Stars/forks activity
53
87 stars, 85 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata
Adoption
68
87 GitHub stars
Warnings
- The provided SKILL.md excerpt cuts off mid-sentence under Golden rule 4, so the full vote-bar verification procedure is not visible in the review excerpt.
- No explicit limitations section is present in the excerpt; for example, handling of delayed ICLA records or secretary response times is mentioned only indirectly.
- Quality score needs review
- GitHub adoption: 87 GitHub stars
- Stars/forks activity: 87 stars, 85 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata
Method
This report combines public metadata, AI review output, repository freshness, install readiness, OpenAgentSkill events, quality scoring, trust checks, and the agent safety gate. It is not a full source-code security review.
Compare nearby options