Skill comparison
Use this as a shortlist, then open the skill detail page before adopting.
Decision summary
Strongest overall
Implement
Use this as a leading candidate, then validate the README and install path in your own agent stack.
Fastest prototype
Implement
Best first install candidate based on install readiness and adoption.
Freshest repo
autoconsultant
Most recent maintenance signal among this shortlist.
| Signal | autoconsultant Autoconsultant owns the approval-gated workflow that takes an ambiguous repository change through a persistent Consultant consultation and adversarial plan review, then prepares separately approved, independent Optimizer and Evaluator instructions plus one copy-paste-safe handoff for a fresh agent. It triggers when a request asks to combine consultation or plan approval with Automake or an evaluator-optimizer setup, preserve plan references, resolve ratchet limits or success conditions, or transfer execution to a new context; explicit `/autoconsultant` also triggers it. It does not own Consultant-only planning, Automake execution, prompt drafting without invocation, plan review without setup, implementation, testing, TDD, Git preflight, or generic workflow explanation. | Code Review Review a branch or diff against repository standards and the originating spec in two independent analysis passes. | Implement Implement work from an approved spec or ticket set, run focused and full tests, invoke code review, and commit the result to the current branch. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 57/100 Promising | 100/100 Excellent | 100/100 Excellent |
| Decision verdict | 56/100 Needs manual review Do a manual repository review before adding this to an agent workflow. | 100/100 Production-ready Use this as a leading candidate, then validate the README and install path in your own agent stack. | 100/100 Production-ready Use this as a leading candidate, then validate the README and install path in your own agent stack. |
| Adoption | 20 stars Verified outcomes are shown on each skill page | 169K stars Verified outcomes are shown on each skill page | 176K stars Verified outcomes are shown on each skill page |
| Freshness | Aug 25, 2026 | Jul 13, 2026 | Jul 17, 2026 |
| Use-case fit |
| Workflow fit |
| Platform hints | Claude Code | Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, OpenAI Agents | Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, OpenAI Agents |
| Warnings | Low GitHub adoption signal · The skill references other skills (Consultant, Automake) but does not include or link to them within the repository; users need to ensure those are present. · No OpenAgentSkill engagement data yet | No OpenAgentSkill engagement data yet | Modifies repository files, executes project commands, and creates a Git commit on the current branch. · No OpenAgentSkill engagement data yet |
| Best for | Coding agents workflows · Claude Code teams · builders willing to evaluate younger projects | Coding agents workflows · Claude Code teams · teams that value GitHub adoption signals | Coding agents workflows · Claude Code teams · teams that value GitHub adoption signals |
| Not ideal for | teams that need a vendor-supported SLA · production agents without a repository review | teams that need a vendor-supported SLA · high-compliance environments without internal security review | teams that need a vendor-supported SLA · production agents without a repository review |
| OpenAgentSkill engagement | 0 views 0 install copies | 0 views 0 install copies | 0 views 0 install copies |
| Install | $ npx skills add eliasstravik/skills --skill autoconsultant | $ npx skills add mattpocock/skills --skill code-review | $ npx skills add mattpocock/skills --skill implement |