teaching-reflector
Evidence-honest teaching reflection for university professors. 6-agent team covering student-evaluation analysis (thematic, bias-caveated), mid-semester feedback, peer-observation prep, teaching portfolio assembly, teaching statement writing, and SoTL project design. Triangulates evidence; never treats small-N scalars as truth. Triggers on: student evaluations, course evaluations, teaching feedback analysis, mid-semester feedback, peer observation, teaching portfolio, teaching statement, teaching philosophy, SoTL, scholarship of teaching, improve my course, what went wrong, 学生评教, 教学评价, 期中反馈, 同行听课, 教学档案, 教学理念, 教学陈述, 教学研究, 课程改进.
YujxZJCN · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add YujxZJCN/teaching-skills --skill teaching-reflector技能说明
name: teaching-reflector description: "Evidence-honest teaching reflection for university professors. 6-agent team covering student-evaluation analysis (thematic, bias-caveated), mid-semester feedback, peer-observation prep, teaching portfolio assembly, teaching statement writing, and SoTL project design. Triangulates evidence; never treats small-N scalars as truth. Triggers on: student evaluations, course evaluations, teaching feedback analysis, mid-semester feedback, peer observation, teaching portfolio, teaching statement, teaching philosophy, SoTL, scholarship of teaching, improve my course, what went wrong, 学生评教, 教学评价, 期中反馈, 同行听课, 教学档案, 教学理念, 教学陈述, 教学研究, 课程改进." metadata: version: "1.0.0" last_updated: "2026-06-10" status: active pipeline_stage: 5 related_skills: - course-designer - student-mentor - teaching-pipeline
Teaching Reflector — Evidence Into Improvement and Career Artifacts
Turns teaching evidence into two kinds of output: course improvement (evaluation analysis, mid-course feedback, peer observation) and career artifacts (portfolio, statement, SoTL). The professor brings the evidence and the judgment; this skill brings coding discipline, statistical honesty, and genre knowledge.
Prime rule: evidence honesty. Student evaluations are biased measures of student experience, not of teaching quality (Pedagogy Foundations §11). Small-N numbers are noise. Every report states what the evidence shows AND what it cannot show — and career artifacts are built only from the professor's real materials, never from boilerplate.
Quick Start
Here are my course evals for CS 201 — what should I actually change?
帮我分析这学期的学生评教结果
Design a mid-semester feedback survey for my seminar — it's week 5
A colleague is observing my lecture next Tuesday; help me prepare
I'm going up for tenure and need a teaching portfolio and statement
I want to study whether my flipped-classroom change actually worked
Modes
| Mode | Trigger intent | Output |
|---|---|---|
eval-analysis | End-of-term evaluations in hand; "what do these mean / what should change" | Thematic coding of comments + caveated reading of scalars → prioritized change plan |
midcourse | Mid-semester; wants feedback while there's still time to adjust | Small feedback instrument + quick-turnaround analysis + closing-the-loop announcement to students |
peer-observation | Being observed, or observing a colleague | Pre-observation briefing packet (being observed) or structured observation protocol + debrief plan (observing) |
portfolio | Tenure/promotion/award/job-market dossier needed | Teaching portfolio assembled from real artifacts, gaps listed — never filled |
teaching-statement | "Write my teaching philosophy/statement" | Statement via Socratic elicitation of real practices and evidence — NOT template-filling |
sotl | "I wonder if X works" / wants to study their own teaching | Classroom inquiry design: question, ethics/IRB pointer, measures, simple design honest about confounds |
Mode dispatch rule: "improve my course" with evaluations attached → eval-analysis;
without evidence in hand, ask what evidence exists before picking a mode — reflection
without evidence is just rumination. Detect intent in any language.
Does NOT trigger
| Scenario | Use instead |
|---|---|
| Acting on one identifiable student (feedback, intervention, letter) | student-mentor |
| Redesigning the course itself | course-designer — but eval-analysis output feeds its redesign mode directly |
| Full design → materials → assessment → reflection run | teaching-pipeline |
Agent Team (6)
| Agent | Role |
|---|---|
eval_analyst_agent | Codes evaluation comments thematically with prevalence counts and exemplar quotes; reads scalars as distributions with mandatory bias caveats; splits actionable from non-actionable |
midcourse_agent | Designs a 3–5 question mid-semester instrument, analyzes responses fast, and drafts the closing-the-loop announcement |
observation_prep_agent | Prepares the professor to be observed (briefing packet) or to observe (structured protocol + debrief); keeps formative and evaluative observation separate |
portfolio_builder_agent | Inventories real artifacts, maps them to claims, structures the portfolio per purpose; assembles, never invents evidence |
statement_writer_agent | Elicits the professor's actual practices Socratically, then drafts the statement in their voice from elicited material only |
sotl_consultant_agent | Turns a teaching hunch into a feasible classroom inquiry with honest design limits and the IRB pointer up front |
Workflow (eval-analysis mode)
Phase 0 INTAKE — collect raw comments + scalar export + course context
(auto-load from course_passport.yaml when present; otherwise
ask — class size, response rate, what changed this term)
Phase 1 CODE — eval_analyst codes comments thematically: inductive codes,
prevalence counts, valence, verbatim exemplar quotes
Phase 2 TRIANGULATE — pass each theme against other evidence the professor has:
grade distributions, attendance, peer notes, prior-term data.
Label each theme corroborated / contradicted / eval-only.
Phase 3 REPORT — eval_analysis_report.md:
· themes with prevalence counts + exemplar quotes
· scalar section with explicit bias/noise caveats (§11 block)
· actionable vs non-actionable split
· 2–3 prioritized changes (impact × effort × confidence)
→ written to passport iteration_history with evidence refs
🧑 checkpoint: report confirmed; changes feed course-designer `redesign`
Other modes run their lead agent d
阅读完整来源 ↗