paper-claim-audit
Zero-context verification that every number, comparison, and scope claim in the paper matches raw result files. Uses a fresh cross-model reviewer with NO prior context to prevent confirmation bias. Use when user says \"审查论文数据\", \"check paper claims\", \"verify numbers\", \"论文数字核对\", or before submission to ensure paper-to-evidence fidelity.
wanshuiyin · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add wanshuiyin/Auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep --skill paper-claim-audit技能说明
name: paper-claim-audit description: "Zero-context verification that every number, comparison, and scope claim in the paper matches raw result files. Uses a fresh cross-model reviewer with NO prior context to prevent confirmation bias. Use when user says "审查论文数据", "check paper claims", "verify numbers", "论文数字核对", or before submission to ensure paper-to-evidence fidelity." argument-hint: "[paper-directory]" allowed-tools: Bash(*), Read, Write, Edit, Grep, Glob, mcp__codex__codex
Paper Claim Audit: Zero-Context Evidence Verification
🔒 Do not wrap this skill in
/loop,/schedule, orCronCreate. It is verdict-bearing — it judges paper-to-evidence fidelity with a deliberately zero-context fresh reviewer. Re-firing that verdict on a wall-clock timer adds no new signal (it changes only when the paper or results change). Schedule the external wait that precedes it — paper draft ready → then audit once. Seeshared-references/external-cadence.md.
Verify that every claim in the paper matches raw evidence for: $ARGUMENTS
Why This Exists
The executor writes experiments AND writes the paper. It "knows" what the results should be. This creates confirmation bias:
- Rounding 84.7% up to 85.3%
- Reporting best seed instead of average
- Citing metrics from a different experiment config
- Claiming "improves by 15%" when the delta is actually 12.8%
A fresh reviewer with zero prior context catches these because it has no expectations — it just compares paper text vs raw files.
How This Differs From Other Audit Skills
| Skill | Question it answers |
|---|---|
/experiment-audit | Is the experiment code honest? (fake GT, normalization fraud) |
/result-to-claim | Does the data scientifically support this claim? |
/paper-claim-audit | Does the paper report the data truthfully and precisely? |
Core Principle
Zero-context, fresh reviewer. The auditor receives ONLY:
- Paper .tex files (the claims)
- Raw result files (the evidence)
It does NOT receive:
- ❌ EXPERIMENT_LOG.md
- ❌ EXPERIMENT_TRACKER.md
- ❌ AUTO_REVIEW.md
- ❌ NARRATIVE_REPORT.md
- ❌ Any executor summary or interpretation
- ❌ Any prior audit results
- ❌ Any conversation history
This is stricter than reviewer-independence — it's zero-context evidence audit.
Workflow
Step 1: Collect Files (Executor — Claude)
Locate paper and result files WITHOUT reading or interpreting them.
Paper files (claims) — paths shown relative to the shell's working
directory so you can find them with ls; when writing them into
audited_input_hashes, use paths relative to the paper dir (no paper/
prefix) per the "Submission Artifact Emission" section below:
paper/main.tex # → hash key: main.tex
paper/sections/*.tex # → hash key: sections/*.tex
paper/tables/*.tex (if separate) # → hash key: tables/*.tex
Result files (evidence):
results/*.json, results/*.jsonl, results/*.csv, results/*.tsv
outputs/*.json, outputs/*.csv
wandb-summary.json (if exists)
**/metrics.json, **/eval_results.json
**/config.yaml, **/args.json (experiment configs)
Exclude (no summaries, no interpretations):
EXPERIMENT_LOG.md, EXPERIMENT_TRACKER.md, AUTO_REVIEW*.md
NARRATIVE_REPORT.md, PAPER_PLAN.md, findings.md
Any .md file that is an executor-written summary
Step 2: Fresh Reviewer Audit (GPT-6-Astra — NEW thread, no reply)
CRITICAL: Use mcp__codex__codex (new thread), NEVER mcp__codex__codex-reply. Every run must be a fresh context.
mcp__codex__codex:
model: gpt-6-astra
config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "ultra"}
prompt: |
You are a paper-to-evidence auditor. You have ZERO prior context about
this research. You will receive only paper source files and raw result
files. Your job is to verify that every number in the paper exactly
matches the raw evidence.
Paper files to read:
[list .tex file paths]
Result files to read:
[list .json/.csv/.yaml file paths]
## Audit Protocol
### A. Extract Every Quantitative Claim
For each number, percentage, comparison, or scope statement in the paper:
- Location (section, table, caption, or inline text)
- Exact claim text
- The number or comparison being made
### B. Trace Each Claim to Evidence
For each extracted claim, find the supporting raw data:
- Which result file contains this number?
- What is the EXACT value in that file?
- Match status: exact_match / rounding_ok / mismatch
### C. Check These Specific Failure Modes
1. **Number inflation**: Paper says 85.3%, raw file says 84.7%
Rule: only standard rounding to displayed precision is allowed
2. **Best-seed cherry-pick**: Paper says "achieves 90.2%" but
that's the best of 5 seeds; mean is 87.1%
Rule: check if paper specifies "average" / "best" / "median"
3. **Config mismatch**: Paper compares Method A vs Baseline B,
but they used different hyperparameters / datasets / splits
Rule: verify config files show same settings for compared methods
4. **Aggregation mismatch**: Paper says "average over 5 seeds"
but result files show only 3 runs
Rule: count actual runs vs claimed count
5. **Delta error**: Paper says "improves by 15%" but
actual delta is (85.3 - 73.1) / 73.1 = 16.7%
Rule: verify arithmetic of all relative improvements
6. **Caption-table mismatch**: Figure caption describes
something different from what the figure/table actually shows
Rule: cross-check every caption against its content
7. **Scope overclaim**: Paper says "consistently outperforms"
but only tested on 2 datasets
Rule: check if language matches actual evaluation scope
## Output Format (per claim)
For each claim, report:
- claim_id: sequential number
- location: se
阅读完整来源 ↗