跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
视频与音频

is-this-photo-real

Verify whether an image or video is authentic, original and correctly captioned — provenance checks, error level analysis, noise and JPEG compression analysis, clone and copy-move detection, lighting and shadow consistency, C2PA Content Credentials, deepfake and AI-generation tells, and the honest limits of AI-detector tools. Use when fact-checking a photo or video, checking for a deepfake or AI-generated image, spotting manipulation, or testing whether footage is recycled or miscaptioned. Applies to KYC and onboarding fraud, insurance claim review, disinformation analysis, and evidence admissibility. Reference at useosint.com/skills/is-this-photo-real.

UseOSINT · 已有静态检查记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add UseOSINT/Skills --skill is-this-photo-real

技能说明


name: is-this-photo-real description: >- Verify whether an image or video is authentic, original and correctly captioned — provenance checks, error level analysis, noise and JPEG compression analysis, clone and copy-move detection, lighting and shadow consistency, C2PA Content Credentials, deepfake and AI-generation tells, and the honest limits of AI-detector tools. Use when fact-checking a photo or video, checking for a deepfake or AI-generated image, spotting manipulation, or testing whether footage is recycled or miscaptioned. Applies to KYC and onboarding fraud, insurance claim review, disinformation analysis, and evidence admissibility. Reference at useosint.com/skills/is-this-photo-real.


Is this photo real

Verification order is the whole skill: provenance first, pixels last. Finding the earliest copy and reading its caption settles more cases than every forensic filter combined, and it produces evidence you can show someone. Pixel forensics produces a colourful heatmap and an argument.

The beginner mistake is running error level analysis on a downloaded JPEG and announcing the image is fake. The second is looking for deepfakes: the overwhelming majority of deceptive media is real footage with a false caption — right pixels, wrong war, wrong year, wrong country.

Triage: what question are you actually answering

The claim under testDo this firstNot this
"This shows event X in place Y"find-the-original-image, then geolocate-from-pixelsAny forensic filter. Recontextualisation leaves no pixel trace at all.
"This is an unaltered photograph"Signal-level analysis, on the least-processed copy you can obtainAnalysing a screenshot or a platform download; both destroy the signal.
"This person said this on video"Provenance, then audio-visual consistency, then face-boundary behaviour frame by frameAn AI-detector score.
"This image was AI-generated"Absent camera physics and incoherent object structureA detector verdict on its own.
"This screenshot is genuine"Layout, font and interface-version consistency; the underlying record if one existsImage forensics. Fabricated screenshots are made in a browser, not an image editor.

Then always ask what the image would look like if the claim were true, write it down, and check for those things specifically. Verification tests a hypothesis; hunting for anomalies fails, because anomalies are everywhere.

Method

  1. Get the best copy. Every re-encode, resize and screenshot destroys forensic signal. Chase the original upload or the agency version, not the platform rendition. Hash it, work on copies. If all you have is a screenshot, say so and lower every downstream conclusion.
  2. Provenance. Run find-the-original-image; for video, extract and search keyframes. You want an earlier appearance, a different caption, a photographer credit, and an on-page date corroborated through read-deleted-pages. An earlier copy with a different caption ends the case.
  3. Metadata. Run secrets-in-file-metadata: editing chain, thumbnail-versus-image comparison, timestamp inconsistencies, whether MakerNotes fit the claimed device.
  4. Provenance signing. Check for C2PA Content Credentials.
  5. Internal consistency. Signage language, plates, currency, uniforms, vehicle models, season, weather and shadows against the claimed date and place, via geolocate-from-pixels. Ordinary detective work, more productive than forensics.
  6. Physical consistency. Lighting, shadows, reflections, perspective.
  7. Signal-level forensics. Noise residuals, JPEG quantisation and double compression, clone detection, colour-filter-array traces. Easy to over-read, worthless on a platform-processed file.
  8. Write what you verified, not a verdict.

Tools and their failure modes: reference/tool-catalogue.md. Ordered by cost: reference/verification-checklist.md.

Lighting, shadow and geometry — the checks that hold up

No tooling, reasoning you can explain to an editor or a court, immune to recompression. This is where to spend your time. Shadow convergence is the strongest. Sunlight is parallel, so in a perspective image, lines drawn from each shadow's tip through the base of the object that cast it must all meet at one point — the projection of the light source. Draw three or four. An object whose line refuses to meet the others was probably not in the original scene; sloped ground is the confound, so use one plane only. Then: shadow direction and penumbra hardness should be consistent across an outdoor scene; specular highlights in eyes, glass and polished metal should agree on where the lights are; a reflection must show what is in front of it, correctly placed and reversed; parallel lines should converge on a common vanishing point with eye level consistent for people on one ground plane; and real lenses leave an optical signature — consistent depth of field, chromatic aberration at high-contrast edges, vignetting, a noise floor that varies with brightness. An element carrying none of that, in an image that has it elsewhere, was added.

Error level analysis, and why it is mostly used wrongly

ELA re-saves the image at a known JPEG quality and displays the difference, on the theory that a region compressed a different number of times responds differently. Four reasons it produces confident nonsense: it responds to content, so edges and texture light up while flat sky and skin go dark, meaning every image has "suspicious bright regions"; one re-save destroys it, so ELA on a social-media download describes the platform's encoder and nothing earlier; it cannot localise a modern edit, because content-aware fill, generative editing and a full re-save leave no differential history to find; and it fails in both directions, with bright regi

阅读完整来源 ↗