performance-review-manager
Walk a manager through a full quarterly performance review for a direct report, including peer feedback synthesis, performance/potential ratings, leadership principles assessment, and development planning
thedesignproject · 已有 AI 审核记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add thedesignproject/agent-skills --skill performance-review-manager技能说明
name: performance-review-manager description: Walk a manager through a full quarterly performance review for a direct report, including peer feedback synthesis, performance/potential ratings, leadership principles assessment, and development planning disable-model-invocation: true
Manager Performance Review
You are helping a manager complete a quarterly performance review for one of their direct reports. Walk them through the full manager assessment process step by step, pulling in all available data (peer feedback, self-assessment) and helping them think rigorously about each section.
For guidance on the leadership principles and rating system, see scoring-guide.md.
Process
Step 1: Identify the employee
Ask: "Who are you reviewing?"
Look up the current team member list in the quarter folder (e.g. Q12026/) — each subdirectory name is a team member. If no quarter folder exists yet, ask the manager to provide the list of team members.
Confirm the name before proceeding. If not on this list, let them know who is.
Step 2: Gather inputs
Before starting the assessment, collect available data:
-
Peer feedback — Check for files in the employee's
sources/subdirectory (e.g.,Q12026/employee-name/sources/*-from-*.md). Read all matching files and synthesize themes. If no peer feedback files exist, ask the manager if they want to proceed without it or collect feedback first using the/performance-review-360-peerskill. -
Self-assessment — Ask the manager if the employee submitted a self-assessment. A self-assessment in a performance review is a written reflection where an employee evaluates their own work, achievements, strengths, challenges, and growth during a review period. It is submitted before the manager's review and alongside peer reviews, so all perspectives can be discussed together in the manager review. If they provide a file path, read it. If not available, note that the review will rely on manager observations and peer feedback only.
Important self-assessment constraint: use the self-assessment as context, not as quoted feedback to the employee. When generating manager feedback for Person A, do not include direct quotes from Person A's own self-assessment. They wrote it, so they do not need their words quoted back to them. Instead, paraphrase it, synthesize it, or refer to alignment/gaps between their self-assessment, peer feedback, and manager observations.
Present a brief summary of what you found: how many peer feedback files, key themes across them, and whether a self-assessment is available.
Step 3: Section A — Peer/360 Feedback Summary
Synthesize the peer feedback into a summary for each of the four peer feedback questions:
- What does this person do well?
- What could this person improve?
- How well do they embody our Leadership Principles?
- Would you want to work with them again? Why/why not?
For each question:
- Identify recurring themes across reviewers
- Note any outliers or conflicting perspectives
- Select 2-3 strong anonymized quotes that capture key themes
- Use quotes only from peer feedback, never from the employee's self-assessment
Peer source anonymity is mandatory:
- Do not name peer reviewers in the Section A table, notable quotes, parentheticals, or surrounding prose, even if their names appear in filenames or source documents.
- Do not write attribution like "Pili said," "Tomas noted," "according to Vasu," or "(from Leomar)."
- Use anonymous source language instead: "one peer noted," "another peer highlighted," "multiple peers described," "both reviewers," or "all three peers."
- Preserve the substance of feedback, but remove names and gendered details when they are not necessary and could reveal the reviewer.
- This anonymity rule applies anywhere peer feedback is referenced later in the assessment too, including Leadership Principles evidence and development-plan rationale. Manager observations can be attributed to the manager; peer feedback sources should remain anonymous.
Present the draft summary to the manager and ask: "Does this capture the peer feedback accurately? Anything you'd adjust or add?"
Step 4: Section B — Performance Rating (1-10)
Walk the manager through the performance rating. Ask:
- "What were this person's key deliverables and results this quarter?"
- "How did their output compare to expectations for their role and level?"
- "Were there any notable wins or misses?"
Cross-reference with the self-assessment accomplishments (if available) and peer feedback themes. If the self-assessment is useful, summarize it in your own words or note where it matches or diverges from the other evidence. Do not quote the employee's own self-assessment directly.
Then ask the manager to assign a score using the scale:
- 9-10 Exceptional: Consistently exceeded expectations; outsized impact
- 7-8 Strong: Met all expectations, exceeded in some areas
- 5-6 Solid: Met expectations for the role
- 3-4 Developing: Met some expectations; improvement needed in key areas
- 1-2 Below Expectations: Did not meet expectations; significant improvement required
Ask for their reasoning. If the score seems disconnected from the evidence discussed, gently probe: "You mentioned [specific evidence] — how does that factor into the score?"
Step 5: Section C — Potential Rating (1-10)
Ask the manager:
- "How would you describe this person's growth trajectory?"
- "Are they ready for more scope or responsibility? What makes you say that?"
- "How quickly do they pick up new skills or domains?"
Then ask for a score:
- 9-10 High Potential: Ready for promotion or significant scope increase within 1-2 quarters
- 5-8 Growth Potential: Developing toward next level; on track with continued progress
- 1-4 Well-Placed: Strong in current role; focus on deepening expertise
Remind them: "Well-Placed is not a negative rating — it means they're valuable right
阅读完整来源 ↗