phoenix-final-gate
Role 10 of the Phoenix Security spec pipeline. Makes the final SHIP / NO_SHIP decision for a Phoenix Security feature spec by checking 8 hard blockers: critical ambiguities remaining, unverified MUSTs, multi-tenant isolation gaps (PSC-03), auth layer coverage (PSC-06), AI agent safety violations (PSC-08), scope creep vs SCOPE_DEFINITION, P0 security not in Batch 1, and active enterprise account requirements (Mimecast, Johnson Matthey, Anaplan) not covered at P0. On SHIP, triggers Confluence push + optional Linear/Slack/Asana/email. On NO_SHIP, lists blockers with source role and required fix. Use this skill for final quality review, when someone says "is this ready to build", "final gate", "ship or no-ship", "is the spec done", or "review the full spec". Can be re-run after fixing blockers.
Security-Phoenix-demo · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add Security-Phoenix-demo/security-skills-claude-code --skill phoenix-final-gate技能说明
name: phoenix-final-gate description: > Role 10 of the Phoenix Security spec pipeline. Makes the final SHIP / NO_SHIP decision for a Phoenix Security feature spec by checking 8 hard blockers: critical ambiguities remaining, unverified MUSTs, multi-tenant isolation gaps (PSC-03), auth layer coverage (PSC-06), AI agent safety violations (PSC-08), scope creep vs SCOPE_DEFINITION, P0 security not in Batch 1, and active enterprise account requirements (Mimecast, Johnson Matthey, Anaplan) not covered at P0. On SHIP, triggers Confluence push + optional Linear/Slack/Asana/email. On NO_SHIP, lists blockers with source role and required fix. Use this skill for final quality review, when someone says "is this ready to build", "final gate", "ship or no-ship", "is the spec done", or "review the full spec". Can be re-run after fixing blockers.
Phoenix Security — Final Gate Reviewer (Role 10)
Token Budget: ≤800 tokens
Depends On: All previous roles (01–09)
Feeds Into: FEATURE_SPEC.md + Confluence push (if SHIP)
Output: 10-final-gate.md
Hard Blockers (any = NO_SHIP)
Run this checklist explicitly — do not skip any item:
- Critical ambiguities remaining (Role 05) > 0
- Any MUST lacks proof path (Role 08,
unverified_musts > 0without downgrade rationale) - PSC-03 multi-tenancy not addressed in security requirements
- PSC-06 auth layer not addressed for any new endpoint
- PSC-08 AI agent autonomous action not gated (if LLM in scope)
- Scope creep: requirements outside SCOPE_DEFINITION from Role 02
- P0 security requirements NOT in Batch 1 (Role 09)
- Active enterprise account requirements (Mimecast/JM/Anaplan) not covered at P0
Soft Warnings (flag, do not block)
- Manual-only proof paths for non-security requirements
- Missing success metrics vs Phoenix case study benchmarks
- Batch count implies >4 weeks without CTO sign-off
- Regulatory hooks not documented
- Competitor brand names in user-facing copy
Output Schema
---
meta:
role: 10-final-gate
session_id: session-[YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS]
token_count: [actual]
decision: SHIP | NO_SHIP
blocker_count: [N]
status: complete
---
### FINAL_GATE
#### DECISION
SHIP | NO_SHIP
#### HARD_BLOCKER_CHECK
- PSC-03 multi-tenancy: addressed | missing
- PSC-06 auth: addressed | missing
- PSC-08 AI agent: addressed | N/A
- Critical ambiguities: [count]
- Unverified MUSTs: [count]
- Scope creep: detected | none
- P0 in Batch 1: yes | no
- Enterprise account coverage: complete | gaps → [list gaps]
#### BLOCKERS (max 10; NO_SHIP only)
- B1: <gap> → source role: 0N → fix required: <exact action>
#### NON_BLOCKING_IMPROVEMENTS (max 10)
- N1: ...
#### NEXT_ACTIONS (ordered; owner + ETA)
1. [@owner] <action> — <ETA>
Post-Gate Actions
On SHIP:
- Save
10-final-gate.md - Compile
FEATURE_SPEC.md(Phoenix PRD template) - Push to Confluence SPM space (Atlassian MCP — mandatory; fallback parent: 1273987073)
- Ask once: "Want me to create Linear/Asana tickets, notify Slack, or email stakeholders?"
- Status: ✅ Pipeline complete
On NO_SHIP:
- Save
10-final-gate.md - Mark PRD status: BLOCKED
- Produce all output files regardless — partial spec beats no artefact
- Fix each blocker at source role → re-run downstream → return here
Chaining
Save: outputs/{session-id}/10-final-gate.md
→ If SHIP: compile FEATURE_SPEC.md using phoenix-prd-generator template