council
Gathers N independent, decorrelated perspectives across model families (external CLIs when present, subagents when not) and arbitrates inline. Use when a decision needs genuine debate — not same-model echo — for critique, review, or judge calls. Honest about degradation: never claims 'consensus' from a single model family.
Rune-kit · 已有 AI 审核记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add Rune-kit/rune --skill council技能说明
name: council description: "Gathers N independent, decorrelated perspectives across model families (external CLIs when present, subagents when not) and arbitrates inline. Use when a decision needs genuine debate — not same-model echo — for critique, review, or judge calls. Honest about degradation: never claims 'consensus' from a single model family." user-invocable: true metadata: author: runedev version: "0.1.0" layer: L3 model: sonnet group: reasoning tools: "Read, Write, Bash, Grep, Glob, Task" emit: council.dispatched, council.result
council
Purpose
One coordination primitive that gathers N INDEPENDENT perspectives for any skill needing debate or multi-view judgment. Detects installed AI CLIs → fans a question across distinct model families → degrades gracefully to subagents when no bridge exists → gates off-topic/malformed voices → normalizes claims → arbitrates INLINE (no separate arbiter skill — single producer→single consumer is YAGNI).
Council's entire value proposition is decorrelated model bias — two different architectures independently reaching the same conclusion is signal; two instances of the same model agreeing is an echo. council refuses to launder the second case as the first.
Triggers
- Called by
adversary— Step 0.6, mode=critique, for plans flagged high-risk/critical-path/expensive-to-reverse - Called by
review— Step 1.6, mode=review, when blast radius is 50+ callers with a HIGH-severity change - Called by
brainstorm— Step 3.75, mode=judge, Design-It-Twice Mode only, when N=4 spawned for a remote/external dependency, diversity landed in the 0.4-0.59 marginal band, or the user requests a second opinion on which candidate design is strongest - Called by
problem-solver— Step 6.5, mode=judge, when a one-way-door decision has a high-impact top solution, or the ethical dimension check surfaced a severe harm/fairness concern /rune council <question>— manual multi-perspective gathering on any question- Auto-trigger: none (always explicit — council is expensive relative to a single pass, callers opt in)
Calls (outbound)
None at the skill level — council dispatches via Bash (external CLI bridge) and Task (subagent fallback) directly. It does not call other Rune skills.
Called By (inbound)
adversary(L2): Step 0.6 — decorrelated critique before red-teaming a high-risk planreview(L2): Step 1.6 — decorrelated bug-finding when blast radius escalation firesbrainstorm(L2): Step 3.75 — decorrelated judgment on which Design-It-Twice candidate is strongest, narrow trigger onlyproblem-solver(L3): Step 6.5 — decorrelated judgment on whether a high-stakes framework conclusion holds (documented L3→L3 coordination)- User:
/rune councildirect invocation
Data Flow
Feeds Into →
adversary(L2):CouncilResult.agreement→ seeds Step 6 Verdict with cross-family-verified findings instead of (or alongside) single-pass analysisreview(L2):CouncilResult.agreement→ seeds Step 6 Report's CRITICAL/HIGH findings for the escalated symbolbrainstorm(L2):CouncilResult.agreement→ seeds Step 4 Recommend with cross-family-verified judgment on the strongest candidate design, alongside (never replacing) the diversity scoreproblem-solver(L3):CouncilResult.agreement→ seeds Step 6's top solution with a cross-family-verified soundness check before Step 7 communication structuring.rune/council/run-*.json: every run's full result — free tier owns this schema; Pro Council Cockpit (deferred, Phase 2) reads it for a live panel
Fed By ←
- Caller's
PerspectiveRequest— question, mode, n, diversity constraints, evidence requirements (see.rune/council-voice-contract.md) .rune/runtimes.json— cached CLI detection from the current session (council writes this in Step 1, ORsentinel-env --agentsmay have pre-written it during env pre-flight — same council-owned schema, council's Step 1.1 cache-reuse path picks up whichever wrote first)
Workflow
Contract source of truth: .rune/council-voice-contract.md (Voice v2). This section is the executable protocol; the contract file is the schema. If the two disagree, the contract wins — update this file to match, don't silently drift.
Step 1: DETECT
- Check for a cached runtime report at
.rune/runtimes.json. If it exists and is from the current session (same date), reuse it — skip to Step 2. - Otherwise probe for the
1devtool-agentbridge (the local CLI that fans prompts out to installed AI coding agents — Claude, Codex, Gemini, Antigravity, Cline, Amp, OpenCode, Qwen, Grok, Aider). Detection and family-mapping details:references/dispatch-protocol.md§Detect. - Write
.rune/runtimes.json:{ detected: [{runtime, status, model_family, version}], checked_at: <session marker>, bridge_path: <resolved path> }— exact field list owned byreferences/dispatch-protocol.md§Detect, keep the two in sync. - No bridge found →
runtime_report.detected = []. This is not an error — proceed straight to subagent-only mode (Step 3 DEGRADE).
Step 2: ALLOCATE
- Read
request.n(2-5) andrequest.diversity.prefer_model_families. - Rank available runtimes by distinct
model_family— prefer 1 voice per distinct family before doubling up on any family. - Reserve mandatory slots per the Voice Contract's correlated-agreement guards, scaled to
n:n >= 3: