跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
其他技能

jarvis-deep-interview

Convergent Socratic interview that turns vague requirements into a production-grade specification via 8-15 narrowing rounds with mathematical ambiguity gating. Inspired by Sorbh/interview-me, adds Contrarian/Simplifier Challenge Mode and JSONL decision log. Use when an idea exists but implementation decisions are still undefined.

Ramsbaby · 已有静态检查记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add Ramsbaby/jarvis --skill jarvis-deep-interview

技能说明


name: jarvis-deep-interview description: Convergent Socratic interview that turns vague requirements into a production-grade specification via 8-15 narrowing rounds with mathematical ambiguity gating. Inspired by Sorbh/interview-me, adds Contrarian/Simplifier Challenge Mode and JSONL decision log. Use when an idea exists but implementation decisions are still undefined. license: MIT

/deep-interview — Convergent Requirements Interview

Acts as a senior architect. 8-15 rounds of Socratic questions narrow a vague idea into a production-grade spec. Blocks contradictions, edge-case gaps, and security gaps before any code is written.

How it differs from /brainstorm

  • /brainstorm (divergent): expand possibilities. 15-20 questions + UI mockup variants. Exits when ideation feels saturated.
  • /deep-interview (convergent): spec gating. 8-15 narrowing rounds + decision log. Exits when ambiguity score ≤ threshold.

When to use which:

  • Idea itself is undefined → /brainstorm
  • Idea exists, implementation decisions are undefined → /deep-interview

Mechanism (4 stages)

1. Mathematical ambiguity gating

After each round, score across:

  • Undefined behavior areas
  • Contradiction risk (conflicting requirements)
  • Uncovered edge cases
  • Security gaps (secrets, PII, permissions)
  • Unidentified irreversible decisions

Refuse autonomous implementation until score ≤ 0.2 (default threshold).

2. Socratic question patterns

Examples the agent will ask:

  • "What happens when X scenario triggers Y?"
  • "What evidence would prove this decision wrong (falsifiability condition)?"
  • "What assumptions are you carrying that aren't yet stated?"
  • "What technical debt will this create one year out?"

3. Contrarian / Simplifier Challenge Mode

For each major decision, automatically run two checks:

  • Contrarian: deliberately raise the counter-hypothesis (debiasing — never confirm a single hypothesis without testing its opposite)
  • Simplifier: check whether a much smaller version exists (Karpathy "Simplicity First" — 200 lines vs 50 lines)

4. Decision log auto-write

All decisions, rationale, falsifiability conditions, and challenge results are recorded in JSONL for later audit.

Iron rules integration

  • No fix without root cause: 5-why on each decision
  • Never lie about status: "don't know" is explicitly marked, not papered over
  • User sovereignty: agent questions are strong signals, not commands — user's answer is final

Self-check (per round — BLOCKING)

  1. Did I compute the ambiguity score with concrete evidence?
  2. Did I avoid confirming a single hypothesis without contrarian check?
  3. Did I run the simplifier challenge?
  4. Did I write the decision and its rationale to the log?

All must pass to advance to the next round.

Limitations

  • Too-divergent input → recommend /brainstorm first
  • Rounds > 15 → auto-pause with "convergence failed, recommend re-divergence"
  • Ambiguity score is a heuristic, not a precise measurement — user judgment is final

Related skills

  • /brainstorm — divergent ideation (predecessor stage)
  • /plan-review — rigorous spec review after this skill completes
  • /verify — implementation verification after spec is built
  • /office-hours — trade-off matrix when a single decision needs explicit user approval

Source attribution

Inspired by Sorbh/interview-me (github.com/Sorbh/interview-me). Convergent gating concept and Contrarian Mode adapted with permission from the open-source pattern.