跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
法律与合规

tax-position-memo

Write a technical tax position memo that documents a tax filing position with authorities, facts, analysis, and conclusion. Use when a tax professional says "write a tax memo", "document this tax position", "research memo for the partner", "we need to support this deduction", "document the tax treatment", "write up the authority for this position", "technical memo on [tax issue]", "MLTN analysis", "reasonable basis memo", "document the IRC section that supports this", or needs to formally document a tax conclusion. Also trigger when someone has a tax question that needs a written conclusion backed by legal authority - even if they don't use the words "tax memo" or "tax position".

qa-aman · 已有静态检查记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add qa-aman/claude-skills --skill tax-position-memo

技能说明


name: tax-position-memo description: > Write a technical tax position memo that documents a tax filing position with authorities, facts, analysis, and conclusion. Use when a tax professional says "write a tax memo", "document this tax position", "research memo for the partner", "we need to support this deduction", "document the tax treatment", "write up the authority for this position", "technical memo on [tax issue]", "MLTN analysis", "reasonable basis memo", "document the IRC section that supports this", or needs to formally document a tax conclusion. Also trigger when someone has a tax question that needs a written conclusion backed by legal authority - even if they don't use the words "tax memo" or "tax position".

Reference Files

  • references/authority-hierarchy.md - Complete federal tax authority hierarchy (IRC through treatises), confidence thresholds (MLTN, substantial authority, reasonable basis), penalty exposure by level, and disclosure form guidance. Read this in Step 3 when compiling authorities and in Step 5 when stating the confidence level and disclosure requirement.

Overview

Based on "Federal Tax Research" by Sawyers and Gill - the standard reference for tax research methodology. A tax position memo is the written record that a tax position meets the applicable confidence standard: substantial authority, more-likely-than-not (MLTN), or reasonable basis. If the IRS examines the return, the memo is the evidence that the position was not taken recklessly.

The FIRAC structure (Facts, Issue, Rule/Authority, Analysis, Conclusion) is the professional standard for tax memos. The analysis section is the most important: it applies the authority to the specific facts. A memo that cites authority without applying it to the facts is not a tax memo - it is a list of citations.

Workflow

Step 1: State the facts

Write a precise, complete statement of the relevant facts. Do not include irrelevant facts. Do not omit facts that are unfavorable to the position.

FACTS

[Client / entity name and entity type (LLC, S-Corp, C-Corp, individual)]
[Tax year(s) at issue]
[Transaction description: what happened, when, who was involved, amounts]
[Relevant background: industry, prior treatment of similar items, elections in effect]
[Unfavorable facts that must be addressed: any facts that cut against the position]

Rules for the facts section:

  • State facts, not conclusions. "The company paid $500K to a related party" is a fact. "The payment was an arm's-length royalty" is a conclusion.
  • Include dollar amounts and dates. Vague facts produce vulnerable positions.
  • Disclose unfavorable facts. A memo that omits contrary facts will not withstand scrutiny.

Step 2: State the issue

Write the tax question as a single, precise sentence. The conclusion will directly answer this question.

ISSUE
Whether [the $500K payment / the loss deduction / the exclusion / etc.] qualifies
as [deductible / excludable / capitalizable / etc.] under [IRC section or applicable authority]
for the [year] tax year.

One issue per memo. If there are two issues, write two memos (or two separate FIRAC sections). Conflating issues muddies the analysis and makes the memo harder to defend.

Step 3: Compile the authorities

List the primary and secondary authorities in priority order. Apply them in the analysis section - do not mix authority listing with application.

AUTHORITIES

Primary (binding or highly persuasive):
- Internal Revenue Code: section [X] - [brief description of what it covers]
- Treasury Regulations: section [X] - [brief description]
- Revenue Rulings: Rev. Rul. [year-number] - [brief description, holding relevant to this issue]
- Court cases: [Case name], [citation] ([court, year]) - [holding and relevance]

Secondary (persuasive, not binding):
- IRS Notices / Announcements: Notice [year-number] - [description]
- PLRs / CCAs (not precedent, but evidence of IRS thinking): PLR [number] - [description]
- Legislative history: [committee report, if relevant]

Note the confidence level each authority supports:

  • Substantial authority (>40% chance of being sustained if challenged): requires primary sources
  • More-likely-than-not (>50%): requires authorities that directly support the position on these facts
  • Reasonable basis (>25%): lower bar; broader range of authorities

Step 4: Write the analysis

Apply each authority to the specific facts. This is the substance of the memo.

ANALYSIS

[Start with the controlling authority and state what it requires]

Under IRC section [X], [quote or paraphrase the relevant operative language]. The
regulations under section [X] define [key term] as [definition]. [Cite: Treas. Reg. X.X-X(a)]

[Apply the authority to the facts]

In the present case, [specific facts] satisfy [statutory/regulatory requirement] because
[reason]. Specifically, [fact 1] establishes [element 1] and [fact 2] demonstrates
[element 2]. [Cite the supporting case or ruling if applicable]

[Address contrary authorities or unfavorable facts]

The IRS argued in [contrary case] that [contrary position]. However, [distinguishing
factor]: unlike the taxpayer in [case], [client] [specific distinguishing fact]. Therefore,
[case] does not control.

[Address the most significant unfavorable fact directly]

The most significant risk to this position is [unfavorable fact]. [Regulation / case]
is unfavorable on this point. However, [mitigating argument]. This risk [is/is not]
sufficient to reduce the confidence level below [substantial authority / MLTN].

The analysis must address every unfavorable authority or fact raised in the authorities section. A memo that ignores contrary authority is not credible.

Step 5: Write the conclusion

The conclusion directly answers the issue. State the confidence level and the specific basis for it.

CONCLUSION

Based on the foregoing analysis, it is our conclusion that [restate the position 
阅读完整来源 ↗