浏览器与自动化
prior-elicitation
Elicit and check Bayesian prior assumptions in meaningful units. Use for expert quantiles, PreliZ, constrained priors, prior-predictive plausibility and prior sensitivity, including power scaling, regularized horseshoe and R2D2 assumptions.
pymc-labs · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add pymc-labs/pymc-modeling --skill prior-elicitation技能说明
name: prior-elicitation description: >- Elicit and check Bayesian prior assumptions in meaningful units. Use for expert quantiles, PreliZ, constrained priors, prior-predictive plausibility and prior sensitivity, including power scaling, regularized horseshoe and R2D2 assumptions.
Prior elicitation
A prior is a scientific assumption, not a scale-free default. Work from the quantity's meaning to a distribution, then check its observable implications.
Workflow
- Define the quantity. Establish the estimand, population, support, units, transformation/link, reference predictor values and information available before outcomes. Separate physical bounds from high-probability intervals, parameter uncertainty from future-observation variability, and independent prior information from outcome-based scaling.
- Elicit, do not invent. Ask for quantiles, probabilities, meaningful predictor contrasts and tail judgments; record their source and disagreements. Label teaching numbers as illustrative assumptions. Do not tune priors to held-out outcomes or fabricate expert answers.
- Translate and check. Use analytic formulas or PreliZ
maxent/quartile. Inspect optimizer status and achieved CDFs independently. Maximum entropy is conditional on a chosen family and parameterization, not universally noninformative. Prefer PreliZ over deprecatedpm.find_constrained_prior. - Simulate prior predictions. Use
pm.sample_prior_predictive(draws=...); access the resulting DataTree withprior["prior_predictive"]. Check support, conditional scales, dataset extremes and scientific contrasts against stated plausibility judgments, beyond observed-range coverage. Revisit assumptions when predictions are implausible, preserving support and simulation uncertainty. These are plausibility checks, not SBC of an inference implementation. - Assess reasonable alternatives. Vary plausible scales and tails while holding data, likelihood, transformations and estimand fixed for a prior sensitivity comparison. Rough exploratory fits can flag which assumptions to investigate; diagnose every posterior supporting reported conclusions with divergences, rank R-hat, bulk/tail ESS, estimand-specific MCSE and trace/rank plots.
- Report the actual sensitivity. Compare physical-scale effects, meaningful event probabilities, uncertainty intervals and new-observation predictions. Stable answers over a few priors do not prove data dominance, global robustness or model adequacy. Power sensitivity is local and also needs reliable importance weights; its heuristic labels are not scientific decisions.
References
- Elicitation, PreliZ, prior predictions and sensitivity — a complete prior-predictive example, unit conversions, expert workflow, analytic checks and power reweighting.
- Shrinkage and regularization — regularized horseshoe scales, R2D2 variance allocation, geometry and interpretation.
Use the installed package's version-matched API documentation when adapting the examples. PreliZ widgets need an interactive notebook; pymc-extras is optional and only needed for its R2D2 helper. This skill does not require another skill.