food-review
Multi-reviewer peer-review system for food & nutrition manuscripts. Simulates an editorial panel — a coordinating editor, three domain reviewers (methodology/statistics, domain/novelty, integrity/ethics), and a devil's advocate — plus a formatting-compliance check against the target journal (APA 7.0 by default, or a specific journal via journal-selector). Grounds the panel first: reads the manuscript's cited sources and the field's key literature into a knowledge base, so novelty and correctness are judged from evidence, not impression. Use for pre-submission review, reviewer reports, mock peer review, or a critique before submitting. Triggers: review my paper, peer review, referee report, reviewer reports, critique my manuscript, pre-submission review, is my paper ready, mock review, editorial review, assess novelty and rigor.
PangenomeAI · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add PangenomeAI/academic-skills-food-nutrition --skill food-review技能说明
name: food-review description: "Multi-reviewer peer-review system for food & nutrition manuscripts. Simulates an editorial panel — a coordinating editor, three domain reviewers (methodology/statistics, domain/novelty, integrity/ethics), and a devil's advocate — plus a formatting-compliance check against the target journal (APA 7.0 by default, or a specific journal via journal-selector). Grounds the panel first: reads the manuscript's cited sources and the field's key literature into a knowledge base, so novelty and correctness are judged from evidence, not impression. Use for pre-submission review, reviewer reports, mock peer review, or a critique before submitting. Triggers: review my paper, peer review, referee report, reviewer reports, critique my manuscript, pre-submission review, is my paper ready, mock review, editorial review, assess novelty and rigor." metadata: version: "2.3.0" verified: "2026-07" related_skills: [journal-selector, food-paper, food-research] subagents: [review_coordinator, knowledge_builder, reviewer_methodology, reviewer_domain, reviewer_integrity, devils_advocate, format_checker] references: - references/review-criteria.md - references/quality-rubrics.md - references/editorial-decisions.md - references/ethics-integrity-checklist.md - references/word-review-comments.md
Food-Review — Multi-Reviewer Peer Review for Food & Nutrition Manuscripts
Give the author the review a good food-science journal would return, from a panel rather than a single voice. Original work; architecture informed by open community peer-review skills (see the repo README Acknowledgements).
Modes
- full (default) — the whole panel: three domain reviewers + devil's advocate + format check, synthesized by the coordinator into an editorial decision.
- quick — coordinator + one blended reviewer pass; a fast readiness verdict.
- methodology — deep dive by
reviewer_methodologyonly. - re-review — re-assess a revised manuscript against the prior reports and the author's response, verifying each point was addressed.
Panel (dispatch via the Agent tool; reviewers run in parallel)
review_coordinator(editor-in-chief) — sets the target journal + scope, dispatchesknowledge_builder, then the reviewers, synthesizes their reports, resolves disagreement, and issues the decision.knowledge_builder— runs first: reads the manuscript's cited sources (Pathway A) and the field's key literature (Pathway B) into a shared knowledge base so the panel judges the science from knowledge, not impression.reviewer_methodology— design, statistics, reproducibility, validation.reviewer_domain— novelty, significance, scope fit, domain correctness (food/nutrition science).reviewer_integrity— data & citation integrity, food-safety/ethics, reporting completeness.devils_advocate— adversarial challenge to the paper's central claim.format_checker— formatting & reference-style compliance vs the target journal.
Ground the panel first — the knowledge base
Reviewers must understand the topic and its background before they critique it.
knowledge_builder runs before the reviewers and builds one knowledge base from:
- A — the manuscript's own citations: retrieve and read the full cited articles, extract what each actually shows, and audit whether it supports the claim it is attached to.
- B — the field's key literature: extract the manuscript's keywords and
research disciplines, search the literature for the field's key work
(may use the
food-researchfull reviewbranch for discovery/screening — but knowledge extraction only, no literature-review article).
A + B give the panel the state of the art, standard methods and benchmark values, consensus vs contested points, a novelty map, and gaps — so novelty and correctness are judged, not guessed. Never summarize a source that was not retrieved; mark abstract-only and unretrievable items. In quick mode, build a light version (Pathway A spot-checks on the load-bearing citations).
Inside food-pipeline (Stage 1 already ran): don't search the field twice —
reuse the Stage-1 evidence base in place of the Pathway-B search, topped up with
food-research quick brief to find the field's key review publications and
read them in full; knowledge base = Stage-1 knowledge + key-review knowledge
(Pathway A still runs). Standalone food-review is unaffected and always builds
the full A + B.
Workflow
flowchart TD
A[Manuscript in] --> B[review_coordinator<br/>resolve target journal + scope]
B --> JS[journal-selector<br/>ask once → journal or 'generic'/APA 7.0]
B --> KB[knowledge_builder<br/>A: read cited sources<br/>B: key field literature]
KB --> KBase[(Knowledge base<br/>state of the art · benchmarks ·<br/>novelty map · cited-source audit)]
KBase --> R1[reviewer_methodology]
KBase --> R2[reviewer_domain]
KBase --> R3[reviewer_integrity]
KBase --> R4[devils_advocate]
JS --> FC[format_checker]
R1 --> C[review_coordinator<br/>synthesize + decision]
R2 --> C
R3 --> C
R4 --> C
FC --> C
C --> O[Panel report:<br/>per-reviewer reports + format check +<br/>editorial decision + revision checklist +<br/>response-letter skeleton]
Formatting / target journal
The review_coordinator first establishes the target journal by calling
journal-selector/SKILL.md (a shared procedure, not an installed skill), which
asks the user which journal the manuscript targets
(they may answer 'generic' → APA 7.0). This is asked once: the resolved
journal's structure, limits, and reference/citation style are recorded and reused,
and format_checker audits the manuscript against them. Don't re-ask unless the
user names a different target journal; reuse the choice if food-pipeline already
resolved one.