food-deep-research
General-purpose deep research that produces a fully written, source-validated literature review on any question: scope it, design the method, discover and screen sources by journal ranking, validate every source, extract and verify evidence, synthesize, stress-test, then write and format the review (APA 7.0 by default, or a target journal's style) and polish it through an editorial + integrity review loop. Use standalone for a deep dive or literature review, or as the deep-dive engine called by food-research. Runs a 12-subagent team with iterate-to-saturation and compile↔review loops. Triggers: deep research, research this in depth, write a literature review, investigate thoroughly, comprehensive review, state of the evidence, briefing on, dig into, deep dive.
PangenomeAI · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add PangenomeAI/academic-skills-food-nutrition --skill food-deep-research技能说明
name: food-deep-research description: "General-purpose deep research that produces a fully written, source-validated literature review on any question: scope it, design the method, discover and screen sources by journal ranking, validate every source, extract and verify evidence, synthesize, stress-test, then write and format the review (APA 7.0 by default, or a target journal's style) and polish it through an editorial + integrity review loop. Use standalone for a deep dive or literature review, or as the deep-dive engine called by food-research. Runs a 12-subagent team with iterate-to-saturation and compile↔review loops. Triggers: deep research, research this in depth, write a literature review, investigate thoroughly, comprehensive review, state of the evidence, briefing on, dig into, deep dive." metadata: version: "2.1.0" verified: "2026-07" related_skills: [food-research, journal-selector, food-paper, food-pipeline] subagents: [research_scope, research_architect, investigator, source_screener, source_verifier, bibliography, claim_verifier, synthesizer, critic, compiler, editor, ethics_reviewer] references: - references/reasoning-and-fallacies.md
Deep-Research — Source-Validated Literature Review Engine
Answer a hard question properly and hand back a written, formatted, integrity-
checked literature review — not just notes. Scope → design → discover → screen
by journal ranking → validate sources → extract & verify evidence → synthesize →
stress-test → write → review-loop → final report. Original work; architecture
informed by open community food-deep-research skills (see the repo README
Acknowledgements). Usable standalone, or as the deep-dive engine called by
food-research.
Modes
- quick brief — scope → discover → screen (Tier 1) → light synthesis → short sourced answer. Skips the full validation/compile/review loop.
- full — the default: the complete 12-subagent pipeline below with the iterate-to-saturation and compile↔review loops, ending in a finished review.
Subagent team (dispatch via the Agent tool)
| # | Subagent | Job |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | research_scope | Comprehensive scope brief: background, problem, significance, central + sub-questions, concepts, boundaries, success criteria. |
| 2 | research_architect | Methodology blueprint: review type, search strategy, inclusion criteria, analytical framework, reporting standard, stopping criteria. |
| 3 | investigator | Pass 1 discover candidate sources; Pass 2 extract evidence from validated sources only (parallel per sub-question). |
| 4 | source_screener | Prioritize candidates by journal ranking (Tier 1 Q1/Q2 + Nature/Science/Cell + other-discipline Q1/Q2; Tier 2 Q3; avoid Tier 4). |
| 5 | source_verifier | Validate each prioritized source (existence/DOI, venue legitimacy, retraction, predatory, methodology, COI) → Source Quality Matrix. |
| 6 | bibliography | Deduplicate + format references (APA 7.0 default, or target-journal style via journal-selector); build the citation map + .bib/.ris. |
| 7 | claim_verifier | Verify each load-bearing claim against its validated source; classify fact/hypothesis/contested/speculation. |
| 8 | synthesizer | Evidence matrix, thematic synthesis, conflict reconciliation, evidence grading, coverage advisory, gap agenda, narrative arc. |
| 9 | critic | Devil's advocate on the synthesis; loop back to investigate if gaps. |
| 10 | compiler | Write & format the literature-review draft (APA 7.0 / target journal); cite by key only; no fabrication. |
| 11 | editor | Editorial review of the draft (5 weighted dimensions, verdict + prioritized feedback). |
| 12 | ethics_reviewer | Integrity/ethics review of the draft (citation integrity, faithful representation, bias, COI, disclosure). |
Workflow
flowchart TD
A[research_scope<br/>scope brief] --> B[research_architect<br/>methodology blueprint]
B --> C[investigator Pass 1<br/>discover candidate sources]
C --> D[source_screener<br/>journal-ranking tiers]
D --> E[source_verifier<br/>validate → Source Quality Matrix]
E --> F[bibliography<br/>dedupe + format + citation map]
E --> G[investigator Pass 2<br/>extract evidence from validated sources]
G --> H[claim_verifier<br/>verify claims vs validated sources]
H --> I[synthesizer<br/>matrix, themes, conflicts, grading, gaps]
I --> J[critic<br/>stress-test synthesis]
J -- gaps --> C
J -- sound --> K[compiler<br/>write + format review<br/>APA 7.0 / target journal]
F --> K
K --> L[editor + ethics_reviewer<br/>editorial + integrity review]
L -- minor/major revision --> K
L -- accept --> M[Final literature review]
Two loops: (1) evidence loop — critic sends gaps back to investigator
(cap ~2–3); (2) writing loop — editor/ethics_reviewer send revisions back
to compiler until Accept (cap ~2–3), then deliver.
First move — set up full-text access (once)
The evidence loop reads actual articles, not abstracts. At the start, run the
food-fetch first-run setup (python3 scripts/food_fetch_setup.py status): if the
user hasn't set up access, surface the one-time highlighted request to provide their
EndNote .Data folder (or Zotero/Mendeley / a PDF folder) or institutional
access, warning that without non-open-access access the accuracy is substantially
limited; save the choice so it isn't re-asked. If they chose "open-access only",
remind briefly of that accuracy limit each run. Don't block — proceed at
open-access + abstract level and flag paywalled sources. Full rules: food-fetch/SKILL.md
and food-research/references/full-text-access.md.
Source discipline (non-negotiable)
- Investigation and claim-checking operate only on validated sources — those that passed
source_screener(ranking) andsource_verifier(validity). Retracted/unresolvable sources are excluded and logged. - **Journal ranki