brainstorm-internal
The divergence technique CYPRESS applies to itself, with no user in the loop — generating genuinely distinct options against evidence already in hand, stating what would have to be true for each, and naming the one fact that would kill each. Use when a choice is the session's to make and the user has nothing to add to it - filling grill.md §7, assembling an ADR's rejected alternatives, choosing between two implementations that satisfy the same contract, or deciding how to sequence work. The user-facing mode is brainstorm-socratic; the protocol owns which mode you are in.
llopresto87 · 已有 AI 审核记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add llopresto87/Cypress --skill brainstorm-internal技能说明
name: brainstorm-internal description: The divergence technique CYPRESS applies to itself, with no user in the loop — generating genuinely distinct options against evidence already in hand, stating what would have to be true for each, and naming the one fact that would kill each. Use when a choice is the session's to make and the user has nothing to add to it - filling grill.md §7, assembling an ADR's rejected alternatives, choosing between two implementations that satisfy the same contract, or deciding how to sequence work. The user-facing mode is brainstorm-socratic; the protocol owns which mode you are in. id: skill.brainstorm-internal tier: 2 kind: skill origin: seed title: brainstorm-internal — divergence against your own evidence, with nobody to ask owns:
- brainstorm-internal.method requires: peers:
- protocol.brainstorm
- skill.brainstorm-socratic
- skill.adr-writer
- skill.grill-planner load_when:
- "generate options for a decision that is mine to make"
- "what are the alternatives, nobody to ask"
- "fill the rejected alternatives of an adr"
- "two designs satisfy the same contract, which one"
- "shaped options for the plan, no user input needed" prevents: A decision recorded with one real option and two invented to flank it, so the rejected alternatives read as due diligence and the choice was never actually contested. est_tokens: 1110
brainstorm-internal
Some choices are not the user's. Which of two implementations satisfies a contract better, how to sequence four increments, what an ADR should record as rejected: the user has nothing to add, and asking costs a turn and gets "you decide". This is the divergence technique for those.
This mode runs with nobody to ask: it sets no pace or cap, waits for no
confirmation, and exits on a written options set. The nine-question
machinery in docs/graph/skills/brainstorm-socratic.md belongs to the
other mode, the one with a user in it; brainstorm.mode-selection in
docs/graph/protocols/brainstorm.md says which mode you are in.
The failure this exists to prevent
A session brainstorming against itself generates one real option and two strawmen. It has already, quietly, decided; what it produces is the decision plus two alternatives shaped to lose. The output looks exactly like genuine divergence (three options, a comparison, a pick), and an ADR built on it records rejected alternatives nobody ever considered.
Every rule below exists because of that one failure.
The method
-
Write the decision as a question with at least two answers you could defend. If you cannot defend the second answer, you have not found an option yet; you have found an objection to one. Go back.
-
Generate against evidence already in hand: the ledgers, the wiki pages, the specs, the source. This mode ONLY reads evidence in hand; web research is
agent.research-scout's, and questions to the user areskill.brainstorm-socratic's. If a genuine option needs evidence you do not have, that is the finding: name it and say which of the two it would settle. -
For each option, state what would have to be true for it to be right. Not its advantages: its preconditions. This is the step that kills strawmen, because an option whose preconditions you cannot write down is one you invented to lose.
-
For each option, name the single fact that would kill it. If an option has no kill condition it is not a real option; if two options share a kill condition they are one option described twice.
-
Say which preconditions are already known true, known false, or unchecked. Unchecked is the useful category and the one that gets collapsed: an option rejected on an unchecked precondition is rejected on a guess, and must be recorded as such.
-
Pick, and record why the others lost, each against its kill condition. The losers go into
grill.md§7 or the ADR's rejected alternatives verbatim; that is what makes this mode's output worth producing rather than reasoning silently.
Honesty checks before you exit
- Could a competent reader of the losing options tell they were seriously considered? If the answer depends on your say-so, they were not.
- Did any option change shape while you worked? Real divergence moves; a set that arrives finished was a decision wearing three hats.
- Is any option rejected on a precondition you never checked? Say so in the record, or check it.
- Did you produce exactly three options because three is the habit? Two defensible options beat three where one is filler.
Exit conditions
- Each option carries its preconditions and its one kill condition.
- Every precondition is marked known-true, known-false, or unchecked.
- The pick names which kill condition retired each loser.
- The options set is written where the next step reads it:
grill.md§7, an ADR's rejected alternatives, or the plan record.
If the decision turns out to need the user's confirmation, it was the
user's, and you are in the wrong mode: brainstorm.mode-selection is
the test, and switching is cheap while the options set is fresh.