跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
设计与 UI

decision-matrix

Compare options with weighted scoring, pros and cons, pre-mortems, opportunity costs, and ICE prioritization. Use when a user wants to reason through a choice, expose assumptions, or rank alternatives.

iflytek · 已有 AI 审核记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add iflytek/skillhub --skill decision-matrix

技能说明


name: decision-matrix description: Compare options with weighted scoring, pros and cons, pre-mortems, opportunity costs, and ICE prioritization. Use when a user wants to reason through a choice, expose assumptions, or rank alternatives. version: 1.0.0 license: MIT

Decision Matrix

What It Does

Apply a transparent framework to compare options, expose trade-offs, and identify what information could change a choice.

Treat every score as a transparent expression of the user's stated preferences, not as objective truth. Clearly label estimates and assumptions, and never invent missing costs, probabilities, constraints, or preferences.

For medical, legal, financial, safety-critical, or other high-impact decisions, use the frameworks only to organize questions and trade-offs. Do not present the highest score as professional advice or a final decision. Encourage the user to verify material facts and consult an appropriately qualified professional.


Frameworks Available

1. Classic Pros & Cons (Benjamin Franklin Method)

Best for: Quick decisions with low-to-moderate stakes

StepAction
1Draw two columns: PROS and CONS
2List every reason for and against — no filtering
3Weigh each item (not all pros are equal). Assign +1 to +5 for pros, -1 to -5 for cons
4Sum the scores, then inspect the strongest items, uncertainty, and any non-negotiables

Guardrail: Pros/cons alone miss hidden assumptions. Always follow with: "What am I not considering?"

2. Weighted Decision Matrix (Pugh Matrix)

Best for: Comparing multiple options against multiple criteria

| Criteria               | Weight (1-5) | Option A | Option B | Option C |
|------------------------|-------------|----------|----------|----------|
| Cost                   |      4      |   8/10   |   6/10   |   9/10   |
| Time to Market         |      3      |   7/10   |   9/10   |   5/10   |
| Strategic Fit          |      5      |   9/10   |   4/10   |   7/10   |
| Team Capacity          |      2      |   6/10   |   8/10   |   4/10   |
| **Weighted Total**     |             |   110    |   87     |   94     |

Steps:

  1. List all viable options (columns in the example)
  2. Define criteria that matter (rows in the example)
  3. Assign a weight (1-5) to each criterion based on importance
  4. Score each option per criterion (1-10)
  5. Multiply score × weight, sum across criteria
  6. Use the highest total as a starting point, then inspect assumptions, uncertainty, must-haves, and reversibility

3. Pre-Mortem

Best for: High-stakes decisions where risk mitigation is critical

"It's 12 months from now and our decision has failed spectacularly. How did it happen?"

StepTechnique
1Assume the decision was made and led to disaster
2Fast-forward and write the "post-mortem" — what went wrong?
3Generate 5-10 plausible failure modes
4For each failure, ask: "What could prevent this?"
5Incorporate those safeguards into the decision

Use this to surface plausible failure modes that an ordinary comparison may miss. Do not treat an imagined failure as a prediction.

4. Opportunity Cost Frame

Best for: Deciding between two good options (where saying yes to A means saying no to B)

FrameQuestion
Cost of yesWhat do I give up by choosing this?
Cost of noWhat do I give up by not choosing this?
Regret testIf I look back in 5 years, which "no" would I regret more?
Opportunity comparisonIf Option A didn't exist, would I choose Option B?

Use the answers as discussion prompts, not an automatic selection rule.

5. ICE Score (Impact, Confidence, Ease)

Best for: Prioritizing many options quickly (features, ideas, experiments)

CriterionScaleQuestion
Impact1-10How significant will the result be if successful?
Confidence1-10How sure are we about the expected outcome?
Ease1-10How easy/simple is this to execute?

Formula: ICE Score = Impact × Confidence × Ease

Sort by score to create a shortlist. Check dependencies, risk, and confidence before selecting work, and re-score when new data emerges.

6. The 10/10/10 Rule

Best for: Emotional or high-stakes personal decisions

Time HorizonQuestion
10 minutesHow will I feel about this decision in 10 minutes?
10 monthsHow will I feel about it in 10 months?
10 yearsHow will I feel about it in 10 years?

Purpose: Shifts perspective from short-term emotion to long-term impact. If the horizons conflict, explain the conflict instead of automatically favoring one horizon.


Trigger Phrases

PhraseAction
"Help me decide between..."Starts a structured comparison of options
"Pros and cons of..."Generates a weighted pros/cons table
"Should I [X] or [Y]?"Runs a decision matrix or opportunity cost analysis
"What am I not considering?"Surfaces blind spots and hidden assumptions
"Run a pre-mortem on..."Scenarios worst-case outcomes to de-risk the decision
"Prioritize these for me..."Uses ICE or weighted scoring to rank options
"Help me think this through..."Combines frameworks layered for clarity

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Define the Decision Clearly

A fuzzy question gets a fuzzy answer. Be specific:

  • ❌ "Should I change jobs?"
  • ✅ "Should I accept the offer at Company X ($120k, hybrid, startup) or stay at my current role ($110k, remote, corporate)?"

Step 2: Identify the Decision Type

Decision TypeRecommended Framework
Low stakes, 2 optionsPros & Cons (weighted)
Multiple options, many criteriaWeighted Decision Matrix
High risk, irreversiblePre-mortem
Scarcity
阅读完整来源 ↗