decision-matrix
Compare options with weighted scoring, pros and cons, pre-mortems, opportunity costs, and ICE prioritization. Use when a user wants to reason through a choice, expose assumptions, or rank alternatives.
iflytek · 已有 AI 审核记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add iflytek/skillhub --skill decision-matrix技能说明
name: decision-matrix description: Compare options with weighted scoring, pros and cons, pre-mortems, opportunity costs, and ICE prioritization. Use when a user wants to reason through a choice, expose assumptions, or rank alternatives. version: 1.0.0 license: MIT
Decision Matrix
What It Does
Apply a transparent framework to compare options, expose trade-offs, and identify what information could change a choice.
Treat every score as a transparent expression of the user's stated preferences, not as objective truth. Clearly label estimates and assumptions, and never invent missing costs, probabilities, constraints, or preferences.
For medical, legal, financial, safety-critical, or other high-impact decisions, use the frameworks only to organize questions and trade-offs. Do not present the highest score as professional advice or a final decision. Encourage the user to verify material facts and consult an appropriately qualified professional.
Frameworks Available
1. Classic Pros & Cons (Benjamin Franklin Method)
Best for: Quick decisions with low-to-moderate stakes
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Draw two columns: PROS and CONS |
| 2 | List every reason for and against — no filtering |
| 3 | Weigh each item (not all pros are equal). Assign +1 to +5 for pros, -1 to -5 for cons |
| 4 | Sum the scores, then inspect the strongest items, uncertainty, and any non-negotiables |
Guardrail: Pros/cons alone miss hidden assumptions. Always follow with: "What am I not considering?"
2. Weighted Decision Matrix (Pugh Matrix)
Best for: Comparing multiple options against multiple criteria
| Criteria | Weight (1-5) | Option A | Option B | Option C |
|------------------------|-------------|----------|----------|----------|
| Cost | 4 | 8/10 | 6/10 | 9/10 |
| Time to Market | 3 | 7/10 | 9/10 | 5/10 |
| Strategic Fit | 5 | 9/10 | 4/10 | 7/10 |
| Team Capacity | 2 | 6/10 | 8/10 | 4/10 |
| **Weighted Total** | | 110 | 87 | 94 |
Steps:
- List all viable options (columns in the example)
- Define criteria that matter (rows in the example)
- Assign a weight (1-5) to each criterion based on importance
- Score each option per criterion (1-10)
- Multiply score × weight, sum across criteria
- Use the highest total as a starting point, then inspect assumptions, uncertainty, must-haves, and reversibility
3. Pre-Mortem
Best for: High-stakes decisions where risk mitigation is critical
"It's 12 months from now and our decision has failed spectacularly. How did it happen?"
| Step | Technique |
|---|---|
| 1 | Assume the decision was made and led to disaster |
| 2 | Fast-forward and write the "post-mortem" — what went wrong? |
| 3 | Generate 5-10 plausible failure modes |
| 4 | For each failure, ask: "What could prevent this?" |
| 5 | Incorporate those safeguards into the decision |
Use this to surface plausible failure modes that an ordinary comparison may miss. Do not treat an imagined failure as a prediction.
4. Opportunity Cost Frame
Best for: Deciding between two good options (where saying yes to A means saying no to B)
| Frame | Question |
|---|---|
| Cost of yes | What do I give up by choosing this? |
| Cost of no | What do I give up by not choosing this? |
| Regret test | If I look back in 5 years, which "no" would I regret more? |
| Opportunity comparison | If Option A didn't exist, would I choose Option B? |
Use the answers as discussion prompts, not an automatic selection rule.
5. ICE Score (Impact, Confidence, Ease)
Best for: Prioritizing many options quickly (features, ideas, experiments)
| Criterion | Scale | Question |
|---|---|---|
| Impact | 1-10 | How significant will the result be if successful? |
| Confidence | 1-10 | How sure are we about the expected outcome? |
| Ease | 1-10 | How easy/simple is this to execute? |
Formula: ICE Score = Impact × Confidence × Ease
Sort by score to create a shortlist. Check dependencies, risk, and confidence before selecting work, and re-score when new data emerges.
6. The 10/10/10 Rule
Best for: Emotional or high-stakes personal decisions
| Time Horizon | Question |
|---|---|
| 10 minutes | How will I feel about this decision in 10 minutes? |
| 10 months | How will I feel about it in 10 months? |
| 10 years | How will I feel about it in 10 years? |
Purpose: Shifts perspective from short-term emotion to long-term impact. If the horizons conflict, explain the conflict instead of automatically favoring one horizon.
Trigger Phrases
| Phrase | Action |
|---|---|
| "Help me decide between..." | Starts a structured comparison of options |
| "Pros and cons of..." | Generates a weighted pros/cons table |
| "Should I [X] or [Y]?" | Runs a decision matrix or opportunity cost analysis |
| "What am I not considering?" | Surfaces blind spots and hidden assumptions |
| "Run a pre-mortem on..." | Scenarios worst-case outcomes to de-risk the decision |
| "Prioritize these for me..." | Uses ICE or weighted scoring to rank options |
| "Help me think this through..." | Combines frameworks layered for clarity |
Step-by-Step Instructions
Step 1: Define the Decision Clearly
A fuzzy question gets a fuzzy answer. Be specific:
- ❌ "Should I change jobs?"
- ✅ "Should I accept the offer at Company X ($120k, hybrid, startup) or stay at my current role ($110k, remote, corporate)?"
Step 2: Identify the Decision Type
| Decision Type | Recommended Framework |
|---|---|
| Low stakes, 2 options | Pros & Cons (weighted) |
| Multiple options, many criteria | Weighted Decision Matrix |
| High risk, irreversible | Pre-mortem |
| Scarcity |