跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
效率与协作

focal-point-finder

This skill should be used when someone needs to find, propose, or evaluate a focal point in a coordination, negotiation, or alignment problem. A focal point is a solution that people converge on without explicit agreement — because it is uniquely prominent, simple, or recognizable. Based on Thomas Schelling's "The Strategy of Conflict." Triggers on "where should we align?", "how do we get everyone on the same page?", "what's the obvious choice?", "find a focal point", "Schelling point", "coordination problem", "how do we agree without talking?", "what would everyone pick?", "propose a standard", "set a default", or any situation where multiple parties need to converge on a single choice without full communication.

gnurio · 已有 AI 审核记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add gnurio/nurijanian-skills --skill focal-point-finder

技能说明


name: focal-point-finder description: This skill should be used when someone needs to find, propose, or evaluate a focal point in a coordination, negotiation, or alignment problem. A focal point is a solution that people converge on without explicit agreement — because it is uniquely prominent, simple, or recognizable. Based on Thomas Schelling's "The Strategy of Conflict." Triggers on "where should we align?", "how do we get everyone on the same page?", "what's the obvious choice?", "find a focal point", "Schelling point", "coordination problem", "how do we agree without talking?", "what would everyone pick?", "propose a standard", "set a default", or any situation where multiple parties need to converge on a single choice without full communication.

Focal Point Finder

Identify, evaluate, or create focal points in coordination and negotiation problems using Thomas Schelling's framework from The Strategy of Conflict.

A focal point is not the objectively best outcome. It is the outcome that everyone expects everyone else to expect — the one choice that stands out enough for mutual recognition. The authority is in the expectations themselves, not in the thing expectations attach to.

When to Use

  • Multiple parties need to converge on a single choice (standard, deadline, meeting point, price, boundary, process)
  • Communication is limited, ambiguous, or costly
  • No formal authority can dictate the answer
  • A proposal needs to "stick" without enforcement
  • An existing default needs to be defended or displaced

Step 1: Map the Coordination Problem

Extract the structure of the situation by answering:

  1. Who are the parties? (List every actor who must align)
  2. What is being coordinated? (A location, a number, a standard, a boundary, a process, a date, a format)
  3. What are the communication constraints? (Full communication? Partial? Tacit? Asynchronous? Cross-cultural?)
  4. What happens if they fail to converge? (Cost of miscoordination — this determines urgency)
  5. Are interests aligned, divergent, or mixed? (Pure coordination, bargaining, or mixed-motive)

Present the map to the user for validation before proceeding.

Step 2: Scan for Existing Focal Points

Before proposing anything new, identify what focal points already exist. Check each source:

The Five Magnets

Uniqueness — Is there one option that stands alone, qualitatively different from all others? Test: "If not this, what?" — if there is no clear alternative, it is focal.

Example: On a map with many crossroads but one house, all 11 people who picked the house met. The 4 who picked crossroads each chose a different one and none met. Three houses would have destroyed the focal point — uniqueness avoids ambiguity.

Simplicity — Is there a clean, discrete option vs. many that differ only by degree? Test: "Can this be stated in one sentence without qualifiers?"

Example: Poison gas was not used in WWII despite no formal treaty. "No gas" is binary and unambiguous. "Some gas" (how much? where? against whom?) creates impossible coordination. The simplicity of total abstention made it the only tacitly achievable limit.

Precedent — Has this been done before in a similar situation? Is there a pattern everyone knows? Test: "What happened last time?"

Example: Middle Eastern oil royalties converged on the 50-50 formula within years of the first deal setting that pattern. Subsequent negotiations had "no heart left in the bargaining" under the shadow of that precedent.

Symmetry — Is there a mathematically or aesthetically balanced option (50-50, equal, round numbers)? Test: "Does this feel 'fair' by default?"

Example: Two strangers secretly divide $100 into piles A and B. If splits match, both keep $100. 36 out of 40 chose $50/$50 — not because it is fair, but because it is the only split both can be certain the other will also pick.

Cultural Salience — Is there something that this specific group of people would all recognize as obvious? Test: "Would a newcomer to this group guess the same answer?"

Example: "Meet somewhere in NYC, no instructions." Most chose Grand Central Station, information booth, 12 noon. The answer depends entirely on the people — a sample from Tokyo would converge elsewhere.

For each candidate focal point found, rate its strength:

  • Strong: passes 3+ magnet tests, no competing focal points
  • Moderate: passes 1-2 magnet tests, one or two competitors
  • Weak: arguable, multiple equally valid alternatives exist

If a strong focal point already exists, present it and stop. The user's job is to recognize it, not to invent a new one.

Step 3: Diagnose Why Convergence Is Failing (If It Is)

If there is no existing focal point or the obvious one is being ignored, diagnose why:

SymptomLikely CauseSchelling Remedy
Too many options, no one commitsNo option has qualitative uniquenessStrip away options until one stands alone
Everyone has a different "obvious" answerCultural salience differs across partiesFind common ground — shared precedent, shared reference points
The obvious answer is unfair to one partyThe focal point discriminatesAccept it if miscoordination is worse, or find an equally prominent alternative
Someone introduced conflicting dataNoise is drowning the signalSimplify: remove extraneous variables
The old default was breachedPrecedent was broken without a replacementEstablish a new bright line quickly, before the vacuum fills with chaos
Agreement in principle, but endless debate on degreeTrying to compromise on a continuumFind a qualitative boundary (river, not "some miles")

Step 4: Create or Propose a Focal Point

When no natural focal point exists, create one using these techniques (ordered by reliability).

Key principle: finding a focal point requires imagination, not just logic. Schelling notes tha

阅读完整来源 ↗