dialogue-polish
Dedicated dialogue editing pass — ensures distinct character voices, subtext, natural rhythm, and correct dialogue-to-prose ratio. Runs AFTER prose-craft and BEFORE chaos-engine.
felipelobomotta-blip · 已有静态检查记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add felipelobomotta-blip/book-genesis-studio --skill dialogue-polish技能说明
name: dialogue-polish description: Dedicated dialogue editing pass — ensures distinct character voices, subtext, natural rhythm, and correct dialogue-to-prose ratio. Runs AFTER prose-craft and BEFORE chaos-engine.
Dialogue Polish
PURPOSE
This skill performs a focused, dialogue-only editing pass on completed chapter drafts. It does NOT touch narrative prose, description, or internal monologue — only spoken dialogue and immediately surrounding dialogue mechanics (tags, beats, attribution).
The goal: every line of dialogue in the manuscript should pass the Cover-the-Name Test — if you hide who is speaking, the reader can still identify the character from voice alone.
WHEN TO RUN
- After: prose-craft (the chapter draft exists)
- Before: chaos-engine (chaos markers may adjust dialogue placement)
- Trigger: Orchestrator calls this skill per-chapter or in batch after prose-craft completes a section
- Re-run: After any major revision that rewrites dialogue-heavy scenes
REQUIRED INPUTS
- Chapter draft — the prose-craft output file (e.g.,
chapters/chapter-03.md) - voice-dna.md — must contain:
- Character voice cards with speech patterns, vocabulary, verbal tics, sentence length preferences
- Dialogue-to-prose ratio target for the genre
- Any character-specific dialogue rules (e.g., "Marcus never uses contractions when angry")
- foundation.md — for character profiles (wound, lie, want, need) to inform subtext decisions
- outline.md — for the chapter's subtext layer definition ("surface conversation vs. REAL conversation")
PROCESS
PHASE 1: AUDIT (Read-only)
Read the chapter and produce a diagnostic before making any changes.
1.1 Dialogue Ratio Check
- Count total words in chapter
- Count words inside dialogue (between quotation marks)
- Calculate dialogue-to-prose percentage
- Compare against voice-dna.md target range
- Flag if outside range:
RATIO_LOWorRATIO_HIGH
1.2 Voice Distinctiveness Scan For each conversation (2+ characters speaking), perform the Cover-the-Name Test:
- Remove all attribution (names, tags, beats)
- Read only the dialogue lines in sequence
- For each line, attempt to identify the speaker from voice alone
- Score:
DISTINCT(immediately identifiable),WEAK(identifiable with effort),INDISTINCT(could be anyone) - Any
INDISTINCTline is flagged for revision
1.3 Tag Audit
- Count instances of each dialogue tag: said, replied, asked, exclaimed, whispered, etc.
- Flag overuse of any single tag (>40% of all tags = overuse)
- Flag "creative" tags that draw attention to themselves: "he ejaculated," "she breathed," "he smirked" (you cannot smirk words)
- Count action beats vs. dialogue tags — target ratio is roughly 60% beats / 40% tags for literary fiction, adjust per genre
1.4 Subtext Check For each conversation, answer:
- What is the surface topic?
- What is the real topic (from outline.md subtext layer)?
- Are they the same? If yes, flag as
FLAT_DIALOGUE— characters are saying exactly what they mean - Is the subtext accessible to the reader? If it requires telepathy, flag as
OPAQUE_SUBTEXT
1.5 Exposition Dump Check Flag any dialogue that matches these patterns:
- "As you know, Bob" — Character tells another character something they both already know, purely for the reader's benefit
- Lecture mode — One character speaks for 4+ uninterrupted sentences of factual/explanatory content
- Question-answer pairs — One character asks convenient questions so the other can info-dump
- Vocabulary shift — Character suddenly uses technical/formal language inconsistent with their voice card to deliver exposition
PHASE 2: REVISION
Apply changes based on the audit. Work conversation by conversation, not line by line.
2.1 Voice Differentiation
For each INDISTINCT or WEAK flagged line:
- Consult the character's voice card in voice-dna.md
- Apply the character's specific markers:
- Vocabulary level (educated vs. street, technical vs. plain)
- Sentence length preference (clipped vs. flowing)
- Verbal tics (filler words, pet phrases, habitual hedging)
- Grammar patterns (proper vs. colloquial, complete vs. fragmented)
- What they AVOID saying (some characters never swear, some never say "I love you," some never ask direct questions)
- Rewrite the line preserving the MEANING but transforming the VOICE
2.2 Tag Replacement For flagged overused tags:
- Replace with action beats that reveal character (not generic actions)
- BAD:
"I don't care," she said, crossing her arms.(generic) - GOOD:
"I don't care." She lined up the salt and pepper shakers so their labels faced forward.(specific to THIS character)
- BAD:
- Keep "said" for invisible attribution where the reader just needs to track who's talking
- Remove tags entirely where the conversation rhythm makes the speaker obvious
- NEVER replace "said" with a verb that is not a speech act. Characters do not "smile" or "shrug" or "laugh" words.
2.3 Subtext Injection
For each FLAT_DIALOGUE flag:
- Identify what the character WANTS to say but cannot/will not
- Rewrite so the surface conversation is about something else while the real meaning travels underneath
- Techniques:
- Deflection — character answers a different question than the one asked
- Displacement — character talks about a third party/object when they mean themselves
- Contradiction — what they say opposes what they do (action beat contradicts dialogue)
- Silence — character does NOT respond where a response is expected (the gap IS the dialogue)
- Over-specificity — character focuses on an irrelevant detail to avoid the real topic ("Did you use the blue mug or the white one?" when the real question is "Are you leaving?")
2.4 Natural Speech Patterns Add or adjust for realism:
- Interruptions — Characters cut each other off mid-sentence (use em-dash at break point)
- **Incomplete th