跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
开发与测试

paper-rebuttal

Guides writing effective rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. Covers review diagnosis (score-driven color-coding), response strategy (champion identification, common-theme consolidation), tactical writing (18 rules), and counterintuitive rebuttal principles. Use when: user received reviewer scores/comments, needs to write a rebuttal or author response, wants to respond to specific criticism (e.g. 'limited novelty', 'missing baselines'), mentions 'rebuttal', 'reviewer comments', 'author response', or 'respond to reviewers'. Do NOT use for pre-submission self-review (use paper-review instead).

CamusGIT · 已有 AI 审核记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add CamusGIT/EvoQuant --skill paper-rebuttal

技能说明


name: paper-rebuttal description: "Guides writing effective rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. Covers review diagnosis (score-driven color-coding), response strategy (champion identification, common-theme consolidation), tactical writing (18 rules), and counterintuitive rebuttal principles. Use when: user received reviewer scores/comments, needs to write a rebuttal or author response, wants to respond to specific criticism (e.g. 'limited novelty', 'missing baselines'), mentions 'rebuttal', 'reviewer comments', 'author response', or 'respond to reviewers'. Do NOT use for pre-submission self-review (use paper-review instead)." allowed-tools: "write_file edit_file read_file think_tool" metadata: author: EvoQuant version: '1.0.0' tags: [core, writing, academic-writing, peer-review]

Paper Rebuttal

A systematic approach to writing rebuttals after receiving peer review feedback. The goal is not to defend every point — it's to move scores by addressing the concerns that actually drive them.

When to Use This Skill

  • User received reviewer comments and needs to write a rebuttal
  • User asks how to respond to specific reviewer criticism
  • User wants to analyze reviews strategically before responding
  • User mentions "rebuttal", "reviewer comments", "review feedback", "respond to reviewers"

For pre-submission self-review and catching weaknesses before they become reviewer complaints, use the paper-review skill.

Step 1: Diagnose Reviews

Before writing a single word, answer: "Why did this reviewer give this exact score?" Not what they wrote — what drove the score. Most researchers skip this and address every comment equally. That is a mistake.

Score Diagnosis

For each reviewer, ask: "What would move this reviewer from their current score to acceptance?"

Score RangeTypical SituationYour Strategy
7+Already your championArm them with ammunition for the discussion phase
5-6On the fence, 1-2 concerns holding them backIdentify and resolve those specific concerns
3-4Fundamental objectionDetermine if the objection is addressable; if not, focus elsewhere

Color-Code Every Comment

Read through each review and mark every comment:

ColorMeaningActionBudget
RedScore-driving concern — this is why the score is lowAddress first, maximum effort and evidence60%
OrangeAddressable concern — can be resolvedRespond with concrete data or revision30%
GrayMinor or cosmeticAcknowledge briefly, confirm fix10%
GreenPositive comment or praiseNote as ammunition for your champion—

Identify the Invisible Question

Behind every reviewer comment is an unspoken question. A comment like "The baselines are outdated" really asks: "Is this method actually competitive with current approaches?" Address the invisible question, not just the surface request.

Step 2: Plan Response Strategy

Categorize Every Concern

CategoryResponse Strategy
MisunderstandingClarify with specific references to the paper; restate the key point
Missing experimentProvide the experiment inline if feasible; otherwise explain constraints honestly
Missing baselineAdd comparison or explain precisely why the baseline is not applicable
Writing clarityAcknowledge and provide revised text in the rebuttal
Fundamental concernAddress directly with technical arguments AND additional evidence
Minor issueThank the reviewer and confirm the fix

Identify Common Themes

If multiple reviewers raise the same concern, it's almost certainly a real weakness. Consolidate these into a "Common Response" section — this saves word count and demonstrates that you understand the pattern.

Distinguish Actionable vs. Subjective

  • Actionable: "Missing comparison with Method X" — you can do this
  • Subjective: "The novelty is limited" — harder to address, but can be reframed with evidence

The Champion Strategy

Your rebuttal's real audience is not the negative reviewer — it's the positive one.

Your champion argues on your behalf in the AC discussion, often using your exact words. Write your rebuttal to arm them:

  1. Make key arguments copy-pasteable — your champion will quote you directly
  2. Highlight where reviewers agree with each other — consensus strengthens the champion's position
  3. Flag contradictions between reviewers — if R1 says "limited novelty" but R2 says "interesting approach," your champion can use this
  4. Lead with strengths before weaknesses — remind the AC what your paper does well

See references/rebuttal-tactics.md for the full 18 tactical rules.

Step 3: Write the Rebuttal

Structure

  1. Opening: One line thanking reviewers (keep it short)
  2. Common concerns: Address issues raised by multiple reviewers first — these are highest priority
  3. Per-reviewer responses: Address remaining concerns in priority order (red → orange → gray), NOT in the order the reviewer wrote them

Per-Concern Format

For each concern, follow this three-part structure:

  1. Acknowledge: Show you understand the concern (one sentence)
  2. Respond: Provide your answer — evidence, clarification, new experiment results
  3. Action: State what you changed in the revision (specific section/table/figure)

Use a fillable template at assets/rebuttal-template.md.

The Neutral Third-Party Test

Before submitting, have someone who hasn't read your paper read only the reviews and your rebuttal. Ask: "Can you tell whether the concerns were addressed?" If not, rewrite.

Counterintuitive Rebuttal Principles

  1. Submit a rebuttal even with extreme scores. A paper with scores of 3/8/8 has better odd
阅读完整来源 ↗