跳至正文
OpenAgentSkill
浏览已开放 · 目录记录日期 2026-11-21 · 自动更新和账户服务暂时关闭。
数据与分析

stats-reporting-audit

Audit, revise, or draft manuscript statistical reporting for Nature / high-impact journal submissions. Use when the user asks to check statistical analysis sections, p values, confidence intervals, sample size, biological versus technical replicates, randomization, blinding, multiple-comparison correction, model assumptions, figure legends, Results statistics wording, reviewer comments about statistics, or Chinese academic drafts needing publication-ready Statistical analysis text. Also trigger on general paper-statistics requests such as 统计审查、统计分析小节、统计方法、p值、样本量、重复数、多重比较、置信区间、效应量、图注统计、审稿人统计意见.

Boom5426 · 已有 AI 审核记录

安装与使用

运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。

npx skills add Boom5426/Nature-Paper-Skills --skill stats-reporting-audit

技能说明


name: stats-reporting-audit description: >- Audit, revise, or draft manuscript statistical reporting for Nature / high-impact journal submissions. Use when the user asks to check statistical analysis sections, p values, confidence intervals, sample size, biological versus technical replicates, randomization, blinding, multiple-comparison correction, model assumptions, figure legends, Results statistics wording, reviewer comments about statistics, or Chinese academic drafts needing publication-ready Statistical analysis text. Also trigger on general paper-statistics requests such as 统计审查、统计分析小节、统计方法、p值、样本量、重复数、多重比较、置信区间、效应量、图注统计、审稿人统计意见. license: Apache-2.0

Nature Statistics Reporting Skill

Use this skill to make manuscript statistics transparent, reproducible, and appropriately bounded. It is a reporting and review skill, not a substitute for a statistician reanalysing raw data unless the user supplies the data and explicitly asks for computation.

Default stance

  • Prioritize design transparency over decorative statistical language.
  • Separate three questions: what was measured, what unit was analysed, and what inference was claimed.
  • Treat the independent experimental unit as the default n; do not silently treat cells, fields of view, repeated readings, spectra, model runs, or technical replicates as independent biological or experimental samples.
  • Prefer effect sizes, uncertainty intervals, sample sizes, and exact test definitions over significance-only phrasing.
  • State missing information as AUTHOR_INPUT_NEEDED instead of inventing sample sizes, tests, software, corrections, exclusion rules, randomization, or blinding.
  • If a journal-specific instruction, study-type guideline, or field standard conflicts with this skill, follow the more specific source and mark the source used.

Accepted inputs

The skill may receive:

  • a Statistical analysis / Methods subsection
  • Results paragraphs containing test statistics or p values
  • figure panels, legends, captions, or source-data notes
  • reviewer comments about statistics
  • author notes in Chinese or English
  • tables of reported comparisons
  • raw or summary data, only when the user wants a concrete reanalysis or figure-statistics check

If the input is partial, run a bounded audit and state which parts cannot be assessed.

Workflow

  1. Classify the task. Decide whether the user wants audit, rewrite, draft, reviewer-response support, figure-statistics alignment, or data-backed reanalysis.
  2. Extract the design. Identify groups, treatments, time points, endpoints, blocking factors, repeated measures, randomization, blinding, exclusions, and missing-data handling.
  3. Define n and replication. Separate independent experimental units, biological replicates, technical replicates, repeated measures, cells/fields/subsamples, simulations, and pooled observations.
  4. Map claims to analyses. For each result claim, record the comparison/model, test family, assumptions, correction strategy, effect estimate, uncertainty, and exact p-value policy.
  5. Check common failure modes. Use references/common-failure-modes.md when the text involves nested data, many comparisons, cell-level measurements, interaction claims, correlations, regression, outliers, small samples, or significance-only reasoning.
  6. Check reporting completeness. Use references/statistical-reporting.md to verify that Methods and Results give enough information for readers and reviewers to understand the analysis.
  7. Align figure statistics. Use references/figure-statistics.md when figure legends, panel labels, stars, error bars, box plots, violin plots, source data, or supplementary figure notes are involved.
  8. Draft or revise. Produce conservative, ready-to-paste text. Keep claims within the supplied design and evidence. Do not upgrade statistical association into mechanism or causality.
  9. Run final QA. Use references/reviewer-checklist.md before final delivery for severity labels, unresolved author questions, and reviewer-facing risk.

Output format

Unless the user asks for another format, return:

Statistics review scope
- Input reviewed:
- Boundary / missing materials:
- Study design readout:
- Independent unit and replication readout:

Major statistical issues
- [P0/P1/P2] Issue:
  Evidence from supplied text:
  Why it matters:
  Fix:

Ready-to-paste revision
[Rewritten Statistical analysis / Results / figure legend text]

AUTHOR_INPUT_NEEDED
- [short factual questions only]

Reviewer-risk note
- What a statistical reviewer may still challenge:

For a clean drafting request with enough information, skip the long issue list and return:

Draft Statistical analysis
[ready-to-paste text]

Reporting notes
- n definition:
- tests/models:
- multiple comparisons:
- software/version:
- unresolved fields:

Red lines

  • Do not invent p values, sample sizes, degrees of freedom, confidence intervals, software versions, correction methods, preregistration, exclusion rules, or power calculations.
  • Do not recommend a statistical test as final when the unit of analysis or design is unclear.
  • Do not accept n = number of cells/images/measurements as independent replication without checking the experimental hierarchy.
  • Do not use “significant” as a synonym for important, large, causal, or biologically meaningful.
  • Do not hide non-significant or weak results by rewriting them into stronger claims.
  • Do not give medical, regulatory, or clinical-trial statistical advice beyond reporting checks unless the user provides the relevant protocol and asks for bounded manuscript wording.

Related files

FileOpen when
references/source-basis.mdYou need the source hierarchy or want to justify why the skill emphasizes transparency, reproducibility, and design reporting
references/statistical-reporting.mdYou
阅读完整来源 ↗