manuscript-optimizer
Use when auditing, restructuring, or revising a research manuscript whose scientific question, claim hierarchy, evidence chain, section logic, figures, terminology, or prose may be unclear or out of sync. Apply before sentence-level polishing, especially for whole drafts, major revisions, resubmissions, overclaiming, experiment-by-experiment Results, inaccessible narratives, or manuscripts that need a claim-driven architecture.
Boom5426 · 已有 AI 审核记录
安装与使用
运行命令前先阅读来源与依赖说明。复制命令不会自动安装或执行。
npx skills add Boom5426/Nature-Paper-Skills --skill manuscript-optimizer技能说明
name: manuscript-optimizer description: Use when auditing, restructuring, or revising a research manuscript whose scientific question, claim hierarchy, evidence chain, section logic, figures, terminology, or prose may be unclear or out of sync. Apply before sentence-level polishing, especially for whole drafts, major revisions, resubmissions, overclaiming, experiment-by-experiment Results, inaccessible narratives, or manuscripts that need a claim-driven architecture.
Manuscript Optimizer
Treat scientific writing as reasoning, not decoration. Do not make existing results sound more impressive. Organize the scientific question, evidence, interpretation, and conclusion into a chain that a broad scientific reader can follow and evaluate.
Use this priority order without exception:
scientific correctness > logic > information structure > clarity > concision > style
Prefer the simplest sentence that preserves the full scientific meaning. Never polish prose built on an unstable claim, a missing evidence link, or a false scientific premise.
Scope and handoff
Use this skill above the sentence level. Own the paper's scientific direction, claim architecture, evidence boundaries, section and paragraph functions, figure-text logic, and terminology.
- Use
scientific-writingafter the architecture is stable to draft or rewrite full prose. - Use
write-scientific-manuscriptto repair paragraph-level clarity and local reasoning. - Use
scientific-prose-stylelast for punctuation and rhythm. - Use
results-section-revisiononly when the claims are stable and Results needs local flow repair. - Use
review-article-architectureinstead for a Review, survey, or Perspective.
For review-only requests, diagnose and stop. For revision requests, diagnose first and then edit in the macro-to-micro order below.
Hard constraints
Preserve the scientific record. Never:
- invent an experiment, result, citation, mechanism, or conclusion;
- alter a number, metric, comparison, data split, configuration, seed, or significance status;
- turn correlation, prediction, sensitivity, or consistency into causation or mechanism;
- turn a trend into a statistically significant result;
- generalize a dataset-, task-, model-, or condition-specific result into a universal conclusion;
- delete an important counterexample, negative result, or metric disagreement to improve the story;
- silently change the meaning of a term or the direction of a comparison.
When the evidence is missing, state the gap. Do not fill it with language. If a design or implementation flaw invalidates a result, stop interpreting that result and report the flaw.
Reader model
Assume a reader who understands the broad life-science or AI domain but does not know this benchmark, dataset, metric, model, or local terminology.
Do not assume that the reader knows:
- why an analysis is necessary;
- what a metric measures scientifically;
- why a comparison is valid;
- why a model or baseline is included;
- why a result matters;
- whether two nearby terms denote the same concept.
Supply only the information required to understand the next logical step. Minimize reader inference without turning the manuscript into an experimental log or a tutorial.
Mandatory workflow
1. Establish the source of truth
Before rewriting, identify the authoritative manuscript, figures, legends, tables, result summary, and project decisions. Preserve citations, figure references, numbers, symbols, and formatting.
Separate the input into three classes:
- Confirmed: directly supported by provided results or authoritative project records.
- Assumed: plausible but not verified from the supplied material.
- Unresolved: missing, contradictory, or scientifically ambiguous.
Do not present an assumption as a confirmed fact. Ask for missing information only when it would materially change the scientific conclusion or revision direction; otherwise flag it and continue.
2. Define the North Star
Write one sentence for each item:
- the broad problem;
- the central scientific question;
- the main claim supported by the study;
- the contribution type, such as finding, method, benchmark, framework, resource, or reformulation;
- the boundary conditions.
Look beneath model comparison when appropriate. Ask whether measurement, identifiability, data resolution, task formulation, or evaluation design is the actual limiting issue.
If the main claim cannot be stated accurately in one sentence, do not begin prose revision.
3. Build the Claim Architecture
Create this artifact before restructuring a whole manuscript:
North Star
└── Central scientific question
└── Main claim
├── Claim 1
│ └── Evidence: result / figure / table / analysis
├── Claim 2
│ └── Evidence: result / figure / table / analysis
├── Claim 3
│ └── Evidence: result / figure / table / analysis
└── Boundary conditions and unresolved points
Use the architecture across the paper:
- Introduction raises the question.
- Results establishes the claims.
- Discussion interprets and connects the claims.
- Abstract compresses the chain.
- Title expresses the highest supported claim or question.
Do not force three claims when the paper supports two, and do not present several contributions as equally central unless the evidence and design require that structure.
4. Map claims to evidence and calibrate their level
Extract substantive claims from the title, abstract, introduction, Results headings, figure legends, and discussion. For each claim, record its exact support and mark it:
- fully supported;
- partially supported;
- unsupported by current evidence;
- hypothesis or interpretation rather than direct finding.
Use the claim ladder:
observation → empirical pattern → interpretation → mechanism → general principle
Write only at the highest level directly licensed by the evidence. D
阅读完整来源 ↗