Laporan audit skill

deliberative-analysis Laporan audit.

Use when comparing non-trivial options or making a design/architecture/experiment/product/research/strategy decision with real tradeoffs, unclear criteria, or commitment risk, and the user says things like "比较一下 A 和 B", "还有别的方案吗", "方案的利弊/权衡是什么", "这样设计好不好", "换个角度", "深入分析", "review my plan", "compare A vs B vs A+B", "what are the alternatives", "what are the tradeoffs", "is this the right approach", or "think this through". Also self-trigger when you only have A/B/A+B, the options are minor variants, success criteria or flip conditions are unclear, or one hidden assumption is deciding the answer; expand the option space and challenge the framing before choosing. Escalate to agent-arena when external evidence or an independent reviewer is needed. Not for simple lookups, formatting, translation, trivial naming/style choices, routine code review without design uncertainty, or when the user asked for a fast answer.

Eksperimental · TinjauPerlu ditinjauDihasilkan 13 Okt 2026Audit metadata heuristik
73
Audit
76
Kepercayaan
49
Kualitas
82
Keamanan
88
Maintain
92
Pasang

Trust Score OpenAgentSkill

76
Shortlist kuat

Trust Score OpenAgentSkill

The Trust Score helps an agent decide whether a skill is safe enough to shortlist before installation.

Adopsi GitHub

Peringatan

48

25 star GitHub

Aktivitas star/fork

Peringatan

43

25 star dan 5 fork; aktivitas issue tidak tersedia dalam metadata saat ini

Pemeliharaan terbaru

Lulus

88

2 bulan sejak push

Kejelasan lisensi

Lulus

86

MIT

Kelengkapan README/SKILL.md

Lulus

86

Metadata memuat konteks penggunaan dan alur kerja yang cukup

Risiko dependensi/runtime

Lulus

90

Tidak ada petunjuk risiko dependensi besar dalam metadata publik

Ketersediaan pemasangan

Lulus

92

npx skills add zhjai/agent-arena --skill deliberative-analysis

Keamanan perintah pemasangan

Lulus

92

Jalur pemasangan paket atau runtime standar

Cakupan izin

Lulus

100

Tidak ada cakupan izin berisiko tinggi dalam metadata publik

Bukti repositori

Lulus

86

https://github.com/zhjai/agent-arena/tree/main/skills/deliberative-analysis

Status peninjauan

Peringatan

46

Persetujuan tinjauan AI belum ada

Hasil terbukti Agent

Info

54

Belum ada data hasil Agent

Pemeriksaan

Tinjauan pemasangan dan adopsi

8 Lulus · 12 Perlu ditinjau

Jalur pemasangan

92

Lulus

npx skills add zhjai/agent-arena --skill deliberative-analysis

Repositori

88

Lulus

https://github.com/zhjai/agent-arena/tree/main/skills/deliberative-analysis

Lisensi

86

Lulus

MIT

Pemeliharaan

88

Lulus

2 bulan sejak push

Tinjauan AI

55

Periksa

Review approval is missing

Kelengkapan README/SKILL.md

86

Lulus

Usable description available

Risiko dependensi

90

Lulus

Tidak ada petunjuk risiko dependensi besar dalam metadata publik

Keamanan perintah pemasangan

92

Lulus

Jalur pemasangan paket atau runtime standar

Cakupan izin

100

Lulus

Tidak ada cakupan izin berisiko tinggi dalam metadata publik

Aktivitas star/fork

43

Perbaiki

25 star dan 5 fork; aktivitas issue tidak tersedia dalam metadata saat ini

Adopsi

42

Periksa

25 star GitHub

Financial decision safety

58

Periksa

Research-only use: do not treat output as financial advice or execute a position without human approval.

Peringatan

  • Financial research output is not financial advice; require human review before any live investment decision
  • Low GitHub adoption signal
  • Persetujuan tinjauan AI belum ada
  • Financial research output is not financial advice; require human review before any live investment decision.
  • Quality score needs review
  • GitHub adoption: 25 GitHub stars
  • Stars/forks activity: 25 stars, 5 forks; issue activity unavailable in current metadata
  • Review status: AI review approval is missing

Metode

This report combines public metadata, AI review output, repository freshness, install readiness, OpenAgentSkill events, quality scoring, trust checks, and the agent safety gate. It is not a full source-code security review.

Bandingkan opsi sekitar

Skill terkait untuk diaudit berikutnya