rootnode-block-selection
Guides selection of identity, reasoning, and output approaches for Claude prompts based on task characteristics. Trigger on: "help me choose an approach," "which approach fits this task," "recommend a prompt pattern," "compare reasoning methods," "map this task to the right approach," "what combination of approaches," "which identity fits," "which reasoning method." Also trigger on symptom-phrased: "my prompt feels generic," "I don't know which approach to use," "my output lacks domain depth." Covers decision-tree logic across 8 identity approaches, 18 reasoning variants, and 10 output formats. After selection, use the relevant catalog skill if available to retrieve full templates. Activate whenever approach-selection across multiple categories is the primary decision. Do NOT use when the user already names a specific approach to retrieve (use the relevant catalog skill directly if available) or for evaluating existing prompts (use rootnode-prompt-validation if available).
rootnode · Static checks on file
Installation
Read the source and dependencies before running a command. Copying does not install or execute anything.
npx skills add drayline/rootnode-skills --skill rootnode-block-selectionAbout this skill
name: rootnode-block-selection description: >- Guides selection of identity, reasoning, and output approaches for Claude prompts based on task characteristics. Trigger on: "help me choose an approach," "which approach fits this task," "recommend a prompt pattern," "compare reasoning methods," "map this task to the right approach," "what combination of approaches," "which identity fits," "which reasoning method." Also trigger on symptom-phrased: "my prompt feels generic," "I don't know which approach to use," "my output lacks domain depth." Covers decision-tree logic across 8 identity approaches, 18 reasoning variants, and 10 output formats. After selection, use the relevant catalog skill if available to retrieve full templates. Activate whenever approach-selection across multiple categories is the primary decision. Do NOT use when the user already names a specific approach to retrieve (use the relevant catalog skill directly if available) or for evaluating existing prompts (use rootnode-prompt-validation if available). license: Apache-2.0 metadata: author: rootnode version: "4.0.0" original-source: "PROMPT_COMPILER.md, BLOCK_LIBRARY_IDENTITY.md, BLOCK_LIBRARY_REASONING.md, BLOCK_LIBRARY_OUTPUT.md"
Approach Selection for Claude Prompts
Calibration: Tier 2 (Sonnet-graceful) — designed and tested against Opus 5 + Sonnet 5 dual-primary. Runs correctly on Sonnet 4.6 (legacy-graceful) with slightly less depth on multi-dimensional analysis; on Haiku 4.5 with extended thinking; fallback-graceful on Opus 4.8. Effort default is
highon Opus 5 and Sonnet 5; step down tomediumfor cost-sensitive runs where evals show quality holds. See repository README for model compatibility.
This Skill provides the decision logic for choosing the right identity, reasoning method, and output format when building a Claude prompt. Given a task description, it maps task characteristics to the best-fit approach in each category.
When to Use This Skill
Use this when you need to decide:
- Which identity (role) fits a task
- Which reasoning method produces the best analytical depth for the task shape
- Which output format matches the deliverable
- When to combine approaches across categories
- When core approaches are sufficient vs. when domain-specific approaches add value
This Skill provides selection logic and approach summaries. For the full approach text (ready to paste into a prompt), consult the reference files in references/.
Important
Be decisive. When one approach is clearly the best fit, recommend it — do not present three options and ask the user to choose unless the options lead to genuinely different outcomes.
Match complexity to task. Not every task needs all four selection decisions. A simple task may need only an identity and output format. A medium task adds a reasoning method. Only complex, high-stakes tasks need the full selection plus quality control additions.
Core approaches cover 80% of tasks. The 8 identity approaches, 18 reasoning variants, and 10 output formats handle most prompt construction needs. Route to domain-specific approaches only when the task requires specialization the core catalog cannot provide. See the domain routing guidance at the end of this file.
Reasoning discipline
A defensible recommendation shows its work. Observe the task characteristics — task type, depth required, audience, output shape, constraints — then name the approach pattern they match against the decision tree, then apply the selection. Compressing the sequence into a summary recommendation blurs edge cases; the explicit walk-through produces selections the user (and a later reviewer) can interrogate.
If the task scope is unclear (single-prompt selection? multi-block combination? architecture decision?), confirm scope with the user before proceeding. Do not proceed on inferred assumptions.
Step 1: Classify the Task
Before selecting approaches, classify the task using this routing table. When a task matches multiple categories, lead with the dominant one and fold in elements from the secondary.
Strategic / Advisory — Business strategy, market entry, competitive analysis, organizational decisions. Identity: Strategic Advisor or Product Strategist. Reasoning: Market & Competitive Strategy, Resource Allocation, or Change & Transformation. Output: Executive Brief, Strategic Memo, or Decision Matrix.
Technical / Engineering — System design, infrastructure, migration planning, technical evaluation. Identity: Technical Architect. Reasoning: System Design, Debugging & Incident Analysis, or Migration & Transition. Output: Technical Design Document or Implementation Plan.
Analytical / Evaluative — Evidence review, data analysis, root cause investigation, risk evaluation. Identity: Research Synthesist or Financial Analyst. Reasoning: General Analysis, Root Cause Diagnosis, or Risk Assessment. Output: Research Summary, Post-Mortem, or Decision Matrix.
Creative / Generative — Concept development, messaging, content creation, narrative design. Identity: Communications Strategist or custom. Reasoning: Concept Development, Messaging & Narrative, or Solution Ideation. Output: Custom, matched to deliverable type.
Research / Synthesis — Literature review, evidence integration, landscape overview. Identity: Research Synthesist. Reasoning: Evidence Synthesis, Landscape Scan, or Gap Analysis. Output: Research Summary or Competitive Analysis.
Comparative / Decision — Option evaluation, vendor selection, prioritization of a set. Identity: Matched to domain. Reasoning: Option Evaluation, Vendor/Tool Selection, or Prioritization. Output: Decision Matrix or Executive Brief.
Operational / Process — Process design, workflow optimization, operational systems. Identity: Operations Designer. Reasoning: General Analysis or custom. Output: Process Documentation, Implementation Plan, or Stakeholder Update.
Read the complete source ↗