Skip to content
OpenAgentSkill
Browsing is open · Catalog captured 2026-11-21 · Automatic updates and account services are paused.
Search & research

paper-planning

Guides pre-writing planning for academic papers with 4 structured steps: story design (task-challenge-insight-contribution-advantage), experiment planning (comparisons + ablations), figure design (pipeline + teaser), and 4-week timeline management. Includes counterintuitive planning tactics (write a mock rejection letter to identify weaknesses before writing, narrow before broad claims, design ablations first). Use when: user wants to plan a paper before writing, design story/contributions, plan experiments, create figure sketches, set a writing timeline, or write a pre-emptive rejection letter for planning purposes. Do NOT use for actual writing (use paper-writing), running experiments (use experiment-pipeline), self-reviewing a finished draft (use paper-review), or finding research problems (use research-ideation).

CamusGIT · AI review on file

Installation

Read the source and dependencies before running a command. Copying does not install or execute anything.

npx skills add CamusGIT/EvoQuant --skill paper-planning

About this skill


name: paper-planning description: "Guides pre-writing planning for academic papers with 4 structured steps: story design (task-challenge-insight-contribution-advantage), experiment planning (comparisons + ablations), figure design (pipeline + teaser), and 4-week timeline management. Includes counterintuitive planning tactics (write a mock rejection letter to identify weaknesses before writing, narrow before broad claims, design ablations first). Use when: user wants to plan a paper before writing, design story/contributions, plan experiments, create figure sketches, set a writing timeline, or write a pre-emptive rejection letter for planning purposes. Do NOT use for actual writing (use paper-writing), running experiments (use experiment-pipeline), self-reviewing a finished draft (use paper-review), or finding research problems (use research-ideation)." allowed-tools: "write_file edit_file read_file think_tool" metadata: author: EvoQuant version: '1.0.0' tags: [core, research, writing, academic-writing, experiment-design]

Paper Planning

A structured approach to planning academic papers before writing begins. Covers four key activities: Story design, Experiment planning, Figure design, and Timeline management.

When to Use This Skill

If you don't yet have an idea, use the research-ideation skill first to find a problem and design a solution.

  • User wants to plan a paper before writing
  • User asks about structuring a paper's story or contributions
  • User needs to plan experiments (comparisons, ablations)
  • User wants to design pipeline figures or teaser figures
  • User asks about writing timelines or submission schedules

Planning Overview

Paper planning follows four steps, ideally completed before writing begins:

Step 1: Story Design     → What is the narrative? What are the contributions?
Step 2: Experiment Plan   → What experiments prove our claims?
Step 3: Figure Design     → How do we visually communicate the method?
Step 4: Timeline          → When does each section get written?

Counterintuitive Planning First

Prioritize these counterintuitive rules before regular planning:

  1. Write your rejection letter first: Draft the top-5 likely rejection comments ("limited novelty", "missing baseline", "not robust", etc.), then plan experiments that directly preempt each one.
  2. Narrow claim before broad claim: Define the smallest defensible core claim first. Expand only after evidence is strong. Over-broad claims fail review more often than narrow strong claims.
  3. Design ablations before polishing method text: If a module cannot be ablated cleanly, its contribution claim is weak.
  4. Allocate compute to stress tests, not only benchmarks: A single convincing stress-test figure often contributes more than multiple small benchmark gains.
  5. Plan a fallback narrative now: If SOTA gain is marginal, predefine a secondary value proposition (efficiency, robustness, fewer assumptions, wider applicability).

See references/counterintuitive-planning.md


Step 1: Story Design

The "story" is the logical narrative that connects the problem, insight, method, and results.

Reverse Engineering the Story

Work backwards to build the story:

  1. What is the technical problem? — The specific challenge that existing methods cannot solve well
  2. What are our contributions? — The concrete technical novelties
  3. What are the benefits and new insights? — What advantages does our approach provide?
  4. How do we lead into the challenge? — How to frame the task and previous methods to naturally arrive at the challenge

Then write forward: Task → Previous methods → Challenge → Our contributions → Advantages

Core Elements to Define

Before writing any section, clearly articulate:

ElementQuestionExample
TaskWhat problem does this paper address?"Real-time 3D scene reconstruction"
ChallengeWhy can't existing methods solve it well?"Cannot handle dynamic objects efficiently"
InsightWhat key observation drives our approach?"Motion patterns are temporally sparse"
ContributionWhat do we propose?"Sparse temporal attention for dynamic regions"
AdvantageWhy is our approach better?"Reduces computation while preserving quality"

Starting Point: Pipeline Figure Sketch

Start by drawing a pipeline figure sketch. This forces you to clarify the overall method before writing.

The pipeline figure sketch serves as the paper's visual backbone:

  • Draw it before writing anything
  • It reveals whether the method is clear enough to explain
  • It identifies the novel modules vs. standard components
  • It determines subsection structure for the Method section

See references/story-design.md


Step 2: Experiment Planning

Plan experiments before writing to avoid discovering gaps late.

Two Categories of Experiments

Comparison Experiments — Prove our method is better:

  • Which baseline methods to compare against?
  • Which datasets and metrics?
  • What is the evaluation protocol?

Ablation Studies — Prove each module is effective:

  • Part 1: One big table showing impact of core contributions
  • Part 2: Several small tables for design choices and hyperparameters

Planning Checklist

  • List all comparison baselines (recent, relevant, SOTA)
  • Define evaluation metrics (standard for the task)
  • Identify datasets (standard benchmarks + challenging demos)
  • List ablation configurations (remove each core component)
  • Plan design-choice tables (hyperparameters, input quality, alternatives)
  • Plan demo scenarios (challenging data to showcase upper limit)

See references/experiment-planning.md

Experiment Plan Template

Use the template at assets/experiment-plan-template.md

Read the complete source ↗