agentsop-llm-engine-selection
Cross-engine decision rubric for self-hosting or recommending an LLM serving stack. Picks among vLLM, SGLang, TensorRT-LLM, TGI, llama.cpp, Ollama, and MLX as a function of (hardware × workload × constraint), not "which is fastest". Activates whenever a coder-agent must choose, defend, or migrate a serving runtime.
agentsope · Static checks on file
Installation
Read the source and dependencies before running a command. Copying does not install or execute anything.
npx skills add agentsope/SkillAlchemy --skill agentsop-llm-engine-selectionAbout this skill
name: agentsop-llm-engine-selection description: Cross-engine decision rubric for self-hosting or recommending an LLM serving stack. Picks among vLLM, SGLang, TensorRT-LLM, TGI, llama.cpp, Ollama, and MLX as a function of (hardware × workload × constraint), not "which is fastest". Activates whenever a coder-agent must choose, defend, or migrate a serving runtime. domain: LLM inference engine selection version: 0.1.0 dated: 2026-05 sources:
- https://www.yottalabs.ai/post/best-llm-inference-engines-in-2026-vllm-tensorrt-llm-tgi-and-sglang-compared
- https://explore.n1n.ai/blog/llm-inference-engine-comparison-vllm-tgi-tensorrt-sglang-2026-03-13
- https://developers.redhat.com/articles/2025/09/30/vllm-or-llamacpp-choosing-right-llm-inference-engine-your-use-case
- https://aimadetools.com/blog/vllm-vs-ollama-vs-llamacpp-vs-tgi/
- https://contracollective.com/blog/llama-cpp-vs-mlx-ollama-vllm-apple-silicon-2026
- https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06180
LLM Engine Selection SOP
State-of-the-art warning. This skill is dated May 2026. The inference-engine landscape moves in 3–6 month cycles (TGI exited maintenance into deprecation in late 2025; SGLang's RadixAttention regressed vLLM's lead in 2024; TensorRT-LLM dropped its proprietary-engine requirement in 2025; Ollama added concurrent-request support mid-2025). Re-verify before betting a quarter of eng budget on any choice below.
1. 何时激活 (When to activate)
Activate this skill any time a coder-agent must:
- Pick a serving stack for a new project (production hosting / batch / edge / dev laptop / multi-tenant SaaS / structured-output service).
- Defend an existing stack against a "let's switch to X" pressure.
- Migrate: justify or block a swap (e.g. TGI → vLLM, Ollama → vLLM, vLLM → TensorRT-LLM).
- Mix: design a multi-tier deployment (e.g. premium tier on TensorRT-LLM, free tier on vLLM-AWQ, dev on Ollama).
- Audit a recommendation that smells like benchmark-cherry-picking ("X is 5× faster").
Do not activate for:
- Tuning a single chosen engine — defer to the dedicated skill (
vllm,sglang,tensorrt-llm,llama-cpp). - Training/fine-tuning runtime selection — different problem class (
accelerate,deepspeed,axolotl). - Hosted-API procurement (OpenAI / Anthropic / Bedrock) — engine choice doesn't apply.
2. 核心心智模型 (Core Mental Model)
Engine choice is a function of (hardware × workload × constraint), not "which is fastest".
There is no global ranking. Every "X beats Y by N%" headline holds only inside an unstated (hardware, batch size, ISL/OSL, model, quantization, concurrency) tuple. Change any axis and the ranking flips.
2.1 The four-axis decision space
- Hardware axis — NVIDIA H100/A100 (NVLink) ≠ NVIDIA L40S/RTX (PCIe-only) ≠ AMD MI300 ≠ Apple Silicon ≠ CPU-only. The interconnect topology matters as much as raw FLOPS [spheron.network 2026]. PCIe-only tensor parallelism collapses; NVLink rescues it.
- Workload axis — production multi-user (throughput) vs latency-bound single-stream vs offline batch vs edge single-user vs structured-output service vs multi-LoRA SaaS. Each has a different winner.
- Constraint axis — license (Apache vs proprietary), vendor lock-in tolerance, engineering budget (1 day vs 2 weeks setup), commercial-use clauses, on-prem vs cloud, P50 vs P99 SLA.
- Maturity axis — the engine's coverage of YOUR model family. A 2025-launched MoE may run on vLLM day-1 but need a 3-month wait for TensorRT-LLM, and may never get a stable GGUF.
2.2 The default in 2026
For GPU-backed, multi-user, open-weights serving, the default is vLLM. It owns the production slot because it is vendor-neutral (NVIDIA/AMD/Intel/TPU/Apple-experimental), supports 200+ architectures including MoE/multimodal, ships an OpenAI-compatible API, and HuggingFace themselves recommend it over their own (now-maintenance-mode) TGI [yottalabs.ai 2026; vllm-project README].
You only reach past vLLM when one of three conditions binds:
- Workload-binding (heavy prefix sharing or structured generation → SGLang).
- Hardware-binding (NVIDIA-only + max throughput goal → TensorRT-LLM; CPU/edge/Apple → llama.cpp/MLX/Ollama).
- Operator-binding (dev laptop, want 5-min setup → Ollama; ≤1 concurrent user → llama.cpp).
2.3 "Fastest" is a category error
Throughput-per-GPU, throughput-per-dollar, P50 TTFT, P99 ITL, and developer-time-to-first-request are five different goals, and the engines optimize for different combinations:
| Engine | What it optimizes for |
|---|---|
| vLLM | Throughput-per-GPU across mixed traffic, model breadth |
| SGLang | Throughput when requests share prefix; structured-gen TPS |
| TensorRT-LLM | Peak throughput on NVIDIA at saturation; per-token cost at scale |
| TGI | Was generic; now mostly a migration source |
| llama.cpp | Single-user TPS on CPU/Apple/edge; minimal-deps install |
| Ollama | Developer-time-to-first-request (5 min) |
| MLX | Apple Silicon throughput and Apple-native dev UX |
Pick by which axis your project is binding on, not by which engine has the most stars.
3. SOP 工作流 (SOP Workflow)
[Step 0] Define the four-axis constraint vector
├─ Hardware: GPU vendor, count, interconnect (NVLink? PCIe?), VRAM/GPU
├─ Workload: # concurrent users, ISL/OSL distribution, shared-prefix %, structured-out %
├─ Constraint: license, vendor-lock tolerance, eng-days budget, P50/P99 SLA
└─ Model: family (Llama/Qwen/Mixtral/DeepSeek/Mamba/...), size, quantization preference
[Step 1] Eliminate incompatible engines (hard filters)
├─ No NVIDIA GPU? → drop TensorRT-LLM
├─ CPU/Apple/edge only? → drop vLLM (production), TGI, TensorRT-LLM
├─ Need OSS-permissive only? → drop TensorRT-LLM (NVIDIA license)
├─ Mamba / brand-new arch? → check vLLM+SGLang coverage; likely drop others
└─ Multi-LoRA hot-swap? → vLLM (best), TensorRT-LLM (good), SGLang (good); ot
Read the complete source ↗